"All share complicity in the destruction of that much under-rated phenomenon called liberty"
About this Quote
Ariel-sharp and faintly contemptuous, Amiel’s line is less lament than indictment: liberty doesn’t die only at the hands of cartoon villains; it erodes through the polite consent of everyone who treats it as an optional extra. The sneer in “under-rated phenomenon” does heavy lifting. Liberty isn’t framed as a sacred abstraction but as a cultural asset with bad PR, something the public chronically undervalues until it’s gone. That phrasing also mocks the modern habit of ranking values like consumer products: safety, comfort, equality, and “good intentions” get five stars, while liberty is left in the bargain bin, too messy, too demanding, too likely to offend.
“Complicity” widens the blast radius. Amiel isn’t sparing activists, lawmakers, bureaucrats, or voters; she’s accusing an entire ecosystem of preference. People trade freedom away in increments, usually for reasons that sound responsible in the moment: security after a crisis, order amid disorder, decency against “harm,” efficiency over due process. The quote’s real target is that moral alibi. Destruction arrives wearing the language of care.
Contextually, this reads like late-20th/early-21st century Western politics: expanding state power, cultural policing, managerial governance, and a public increasingly comfortable with restrictions so long as they’re marketed as protection. The punch is its refusal to let anyone stand outside the crime scene. Liberty, Amiel implies, isn’t murdered; it’s co-signed away, one reasonable compromise at a time.
“Complicity” widens the blast radius. Amiel isn’t sparing activists, lawmakers, bureaucrats, or voters; she’s accusing an entire ecosystem of preference. People trade freedom away in increments, usually for reasons that sound responsible in the moment: security after a crisis, order amid disorder, decency against “harm,” efficiency over due process. The quote’s real target is that moral alibi. Destruction arrives wearing the language of care.
Contextually, this reads like late-20th/early-21st century Western politics: expanding state power, cultural policing, managerial governance, and a public increasingly comfortable with restrictions so long as they’re marketed as protection. The punch is its refusal to let anyone stand outside the crime scene. Liberty, Amiel implies, isn’t murdered; it’s co-signed away, one reasonable compromise at a time.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Barbara
Add to List







