"All stories should have some honesty and truth in them, otherwise you're just playing about"
About this Quote
Kneale’s line is a quiet provocation disguised as craft advice: if your fiction isn’t tethered to honesty, it’s not harmless escapism, it’s unserious playacting. Coming from a writer who made paranoia feel domestic (The Quatermass Experiment, The Stone Tape), “truth” here isn’t about fact-checking. It’s about moral and psychological accuracy: does the story admit what people are actually like, what power does, what fear sounds like at 2 a.m. in a fluorescent-lit corridor?
The phrasing does a lot of work. “Should” lands as an ethical obligation, not a preference. “Some honesty and truth” is deliberately modest, suggesting Kneale isn’t demanding realism or confession, just an anchor point the audience can recognize in themselves. Then he sharpens the blade with “otherwise you’re just playing about,” a British dismissal that reads almost affectionate but carries real contempt for empty genre mechanics and decorative cleverness. It’s a warning against writing that treats plot like a toy and characters like puppets.
Context matters: Kneale’s career sat at the hinge between postwar austerity and the mass reach of television, when genre could either anesthetize or interrogate. His best work smuggles social critique through suspense, turning aliens and hauntings into instruments for talking about institutions, technology, class, and collective delusion. The subtext is blunt: entertainment is fine, but if you’re not risking a truth - about the world or yourself - you’re not making stories. You’re avoiding them.
The phrasing does a lot of work. “Should” lands as an ethical obligation, not a preference. “Some honesty and truth” is deliberately modest, suggesting Kneale isn’t demanding realism or confession, just an anchor point the audience can recognize in themselves. Then he sharpens the blade with “otherwise you’re just playing about,” a British dismissal that reads almost affectionate but carries real contempt for empty genre mechanics and decorative cleverness. It’s a warning against writing that treats plot like a toy and characters like puppets.
Context matters: Kneale’s career sat at the hinge between postwar austerity and the mass reach of television, when genre could either anesthetize or interrogate. His best work smuggles social critique through suspense, turning aliens and hauntings into instruments for talking about institutions, technology, class, and collective delusion. The subtext is blunt: entertainment is fine, but if you’re not risking a truth - about the world or yourself - you’re not making stories. You’re avoiding them.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Nigel
Add to List
