"All that is human must retrograde if it does not advance"
About this Quote
Progress, in Gibbon's hands, is less a cheerful banner than a threat: keep moving or be dragged backward. "All that is human must retrograde if it does not advance" is a historian's version of a law of physics, and it carries the chill of someone who has spent years watching empires mistake stability for permanence. The verb "must" does the heavy lifting. This isn't advice about self-improvement; it's a diagnosis of civilizational entropy. For Gibbon, standing still is a fantasy available only to those who haven't looked closely at institutions under stress.
The line also smuggles in an Enlightenment confidence that history is intelligible and that improvement is possible - paired with an Augustan pessimism about how rarely we earn it. "All that is human" widens the blast radius beyond Rome to churches, courts, armies, and habits of mind. Gibbon isn't talking about personal ambition so much as the upkeep of complex systems: laws that require renewal, knowledge that decays into dogma, virtue that curdles into performance. If you stop cultivating, you don't preserve; you ossify.
Context matters: writing in the long shadow of Rome's fall and on the eve of revolutionary Europe, Gibbon is wary of narratives that treat decline as sudden catastrophe. Retrogression arrives by comfort, by administrative laziness, by the slow substitution of ritual for reason. The sentence is elegant because it denies the reader a neutral option. It weaponizes time itself: history is not a museum you can leave unattended.
The line also smuggles in an Enlightenment confidence that history is intelligible and that improvement is possible - paired with an Augustan pessimism about how rarely we earn it. "All that is human" widens the blast radius beyond Rome to churches, courts, armies, and habits of mind. Gibbon isn't talking about personal ambition so much as the upkeep of complex systems: laws that require renewal, knowledge that decays into dogma, virtue that curdles into performance. If you stop cultivating, you don't preserve; you ossify.
Context matters: writing in the long shadow of Rome's fall and on the eve of revolutionary Europe, Gibbon is wary of narratives that treat decline as sudden catastrophe. Retrogression arrives by comfort, by administrative laziness, by the slow substitution of ritual for reason. The sentence is elegant because it denies the reader a neutral option. It weaponizes time itself: history is not a museum you can leave unattended.
Quote Details
| Topic | Change |
|---|
More Quotes by Edward
Add to List






