"All violent feelings have the same effect. They produce in us a falseness in all our impressions of external things, which I would generally characterize as the pathetic fallacy"
About this Quote
Ruskin is doing something slyly radical here: he’s not merely warning against melodrama, he’s diagnosing emotion as a perceptual glitch. “All violent feelings” don’t just make us expressive; they make us inaccurate. The phrase “falseness in all our impressions” turns passion into a kind of optical distortion, a smear on the lens through which we see “external things.” That’s a direct shot at the Romantic habit of projecting inner weather onto outer weather, treating nature as a sympathetic character rather than an indifferent system.
His coined term, “pathetic fallacy,” works because it sounds like a technical error, not a moral failing. Pathetic in the older sense (pathos) is smuggled into fallacy, suggesting that feeling isn’t embarrassing, just epistemically unreliable. The subtext is classic Victorian seriousness: art has obligations, and one of them is truthful perception. When emotion makes clouds “sullen” or the sea “cruel,” the writer isn’t deep; the writer is, in Ruskin’s view, temporarily untrustworthy.
Context matters. Ruskin is writing in a 19th-century Britain arguing about realism, moral instruction, and the social role of art. Industrial modernity is reshaping the landscape and the psyche; Romantic projection can look like a retreat into private sensation. Ruskin’s intent isn’t to ban feeling but to rank it. He admires the artist who can feel intensely and still render the world with steadiness, implying that mature imagination is not overflow but discipline: emotion, yes, but not at the expense of seeing straight.
His coined term, “pathetic fallacy,” works because it sounds like a technical error, not a moral failing. Pathetic in the older sense (pathos) is smuggled into fallacy, suggesting that feeling isn’t embarrassing, just epistemically unreliable. The subtext is classic Victorian seriousness: art has obligations, and one of them is truthful perception. When emotion makes clouds “sullen” or the sea “cruel,” the writer isn’t deep; the writer is, in Ruskin’s view, temporarily untrustworthy.
Context matters. Ruskin is writing in a 19th-century Britain arguing about realism, moral instruction, and the social role of art. Industrial modernity is reshaping the landscape and the psyche; Romantic projection can look like a retreat into private sensation. Ruskin’s intent isn’t to ban feeling but to rank it. He admires the artist who can feel intensely and still render the world with steadiness, implying that mature imagination is not overflow but discipline: emotion, yes, but not at the expense of seeing straight.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by John
Add to List
