"Almost any game with any ball is a good game"
About this Quote
A sociologist praising ball games isn’t just being folksy; he’s smuggling in a theory of social glue. “Almost any game with any ball is a good game” sounds breezy, but it’s built like a field note: low on ideology, high on observation. Lynd isn’t arguing that every sport is equal. He’s suggesting that the ball itself is an elegant social technology - cheap, portable, and instantly legible. Put a ball in a group’s path and you get rules, roles, conflict, cooperation, and status negotiations in miniature.
The key word is “almost.” That hedge is doing real work. It admits the exceptions - exclusionary teams, violent competitiveness, the kid who never gets picked - while still insisting that the baseline tendency of play is toward connection. The phrase “with any ball” democratizes the whole thing. It’s not about sanctioned leagues or pristine equipment; it’s about improvisation. A scuffed baseball, a rolled-up sock, a borrowed soccer ball: the point is the shared pretense that this object matters, and the shared agreement to act accordingly.
In Lynd’s era, when he was studying communities and the texture of everyday American life, this kind of claim doubles as a defense of ordinary leisure against the anxieties of modernity. Industrial schedules and consumer culture can fracture people into isolated roles. A ball game, by contrast, rebuilds a temporary commons: a place where the rules are negotiated face-to-face, and belonging is earned in motion, not declared on paper.
The key word is “almost.” That hedge is doing real work. It admits the exceptions - exclusionary teams, violent competitiveness, the kid who never gets picked - while still insisting that the baseline tendency of play is toward connection. The phrase “with any ball” democratizes the whole thing. It’s not about sanctioned leagues or pristine equipment; it’s about improvisation. A scuffed baseball, a rolled-up sock, a borrowed soccer ball: the point is the shared pretense that this object matters, and the shared agreement to act accordingly.
In Lynd’s era, when he was studying communities and the texture of everyday American life, this kind of claim doubles as a defense of ordinary leisure against the anxieties of modernity. Industrial schedules and consumer culture can fracture people into isolated roles. A ball game, by contrast, rebuilds a temporary commons: a place where the rules are negotiated face-to-face, and belonging is earned in motion, not declared on paper.
Quote Details
| Topic | Sports |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List
