"Almost every desire a poor man has is a punishable offence"
About this Quote
Celine’s line lands like a courtroom verdict disguised as a sociological observation: poverty doesn’t just limit choices, it criminalizes them. The nastiest trick here is the word “desire.” He’s not talking about grand crimes; he’s talking about wanting what the world insists is ordinary - rest, pleasure, mobility, dignity, a little excess, the right to take up space. For the poor, even longing can look like loitering, trespassing, theft-in-waiting. “Almost every” is doing cynical work, too: the hyperbole isn’t sloppy, it’s strategic, suggesting a system so thoroughly rigged that exception is the rarity.
Celine’s specific intent is less to plead for sympathy than to indict the machinery that turns deprivation into deviance. The subtext is that law and morality aren’t neutral; they’re class instruments. The poor get policed not only for what they do, but for what their desires imply: potential disorder, potential claims on resources, potential refusal to stay in their assigned place. In that sense, punishment isn’t merely reactive - it’s preventative, a way to keep aspiration from becoming action.
Context matters because Celine wrote with a corrosive, anti-sentimental eye shaped by war, urban misery, and a deep suspicion of bourgeois respectability. He’s describing modernity’s bargain: the market dangles comforts as democratic, then the state enforces scarcity as if it were personal failure. The line works because it compresses a whole social theory into a single bleak joke: the poor are guilty of wanting.
Celine’s specific intent is less to plead for sympathy than to indict the machinery that turns deprivation into deviance. The subtext is that law and morality aren’t neutral; they’re class instruments. The poor get policed not only for what they do, but for what their desires imply: potential disorder, potential claims on resources, potential refusal to stay in their assigned place. In that sense, punishment isn’t merely reactive - it’s preventative, a way to keep aspiration from becoming action.
Context matters because Celine wrote with a corrosive, anti-sentimental eye shaped by war, urban misery, and a deep suspicion of bourgeois respectability. He’s describing modernity’s bargain: the market dangles comforts as democratic, then the state enforces scarcity as if it were personal failure. The line works because it compresses a whole social theory into a single bleak joke: the poor are guilty of wanting.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|
More Quotes by Louis-Ferdinand
Add to List












