"Almost everybody is enthusiastic about the promise of biotechnology to cure disease and to relieve suffering"
About this Quote
Biotechnology is framed here as the rare modern project that seems to float above politics: who, after all, is going to argue against curing disease? Leon Kass opens with that apparent consensus not to celebrate it, but to box it in. The line’s key move is rhetorical: “almost everybody” signals broad approval while leaving a strategic sliver of dissent. Kass is marking himself as part of that sliver - not as an enemy of medicine, but as the person willing to ask the impolite questions once the applause dies down.
The subtext is caution disguised as agreement. By leaning on “promise,” he emphasizes that biotech’s moral halo is anticipatory, built on future benefits that can be used to justify present-day risks. “Relieve suffering” functions as an ethical trump card, the language that ends arguments before they start. Kass’s deeper worry, consistent with his bioethics work and his role in early-2000s U.S. policy debates, is that humanitarian goals can become a blank check: if the aim is noble enough, any technique starts to look inevitable, and any critic starts to look cruel.
Context matters: Kass wrote and spoke during a period when stem cells, cloning anxieties, and the emerging talk of “enhancement” blurred the boundary between treating illness and redesigning human life. The sentence is the calm first step in a staircase: yes, we want the cures. Now let’s talk about what we might trade away - humility, limits, even a shared sense of what counts as being human - when “relief of suffering” becomes the only public language we’re allowed to use.
The subtext is caution disguised as agreement. By leaning on “promise,” he emphasizes that biotech’s moral halo is anticipatory, built on future benefits that can be used to justify present-day risks. “Relieve suffering” functions as an ethical trump card, the language that ends arguments before they start. Kass’s deeper worry, consistent with his bioethics work and his role in early-2000s U.S. policy debates, is that humanitarian goals can become a blank check: if the aim is noble enough, any technique starts to look inevitable, and any critic starts to look cruel.
Context matters: Kass wrote and spoke during a period when stem cells, cloning anxieties, and the emerging talk of “enhancement” blurred the boundary between treating illness and redesigning human life. The sentence is the calm first step in a staircase: yes, we want the cures. Now let’s talk about what we might trade away - humility, limits, even a shared sense of what counts as being human - when “relief of suffering” becomes the only public language we’re allowed to use.
Quote Details
| Topic | Health |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Leon
Add to List



