"Although mountains may guide migrations, the plains are the regions where people dwell in greatest numbers"
About this Quote
A neat, confident generalization doing the quiet work of early 20th-century social science: it turns geography into destiny while sounding like common sense. Huntington’s line divides the world into two roles. Mountains are dramatic but essentially transitional - they “guide migrations,” shaping movement like corridors and gates. Plains, by contrast, are where human life supposedly settles into its most “natural” form: stability, density, agriculture, state power. It’s an argument that flat land is not just convenient but historically normative.
The phrasing matters. “May guide” grants mountains a conditional, almost secondary agency, while “are the regions” lands like a verdict. “People dwell in greatest numbers” frames population as the measure of legitimacy: the place where most humans live becomes the place that matters. That’s not a neutral observation; it’s a value system smuggled in as description. It sidelines highland societies as marginal, exceptional, or merely in the way - useful for explaining movement, not for representing civilization.
Context sharpens the edge. Huntington was a prominent environmental determinist, writing in an era hungry for scientific-sounding laws to explain why some regions amassed wealth and empires. The sentence reads like a map that doubles as a hierarchy. Plains become the stage for “real” history; mountains become obstacles, refuges, or routes.
It also anticipates modern demographic logic: density equals importance. Today we’d add caveats about trade, technology, and political choice. Huntington’s clean division still tempts because it compresses messy human stories into a single, legible rule.
The phrasing matters. “May guide” grants mountains a conditional, almost secondary agency, while “are the regions” lands like a verdict. “People dwell in greatest numbers” frames population as the measure of legitimacy: the place where most humans live becomes the place that matters. That’s not a neutral observation; it’s a value system smuggled in as description. It sidelines highland societies as marginal, exceptional, or merely in the way - useful for explaining movement, not for representing civilization.
Context sharpens the edge. Huntington was a prominent environmental determinist, writing in an era hungry for scientific-sounding laws to explain why some regions amassed wealth and empires. The sentence reads like a map that doubles as a hierarchy. Plains become the stage for “real” history; mountains become obstacles, refuges, or routes.
It also anticipates modern demographic logic: density equals importance. Today we’d add caveats about trade, technology, and political choice. Huntington’s clean division still tempts because it compresses messy human stories into a single, legible rule.
Quote Details
| Topic | Nature |
|---|
More Quotes by Ellsworth
Add to List







