"Although none of the rules for becoming more alive is valid, it is healthy to keep on formulating them"
About this Quote
Sontag slips a paradox into a self-help shape, then breaks the mold. “None of the rules for becoming more alive is valid” is a refusal of the consoling fantasy that vitality can be systematized. If you could bullet-point your way into intensity, aliveness would be just another consumer product: measurable, replicable, ultimately deadening. Yet she doesn’t dunk on the impulse to make rules; she diagnoses it as “healthy” to keep trying. The verb “formulating” matters. It’s not “following” rules, it’s drafting them, revising them, treating the self as a living document rather than a fixed project plan.
The subtext is classic Sontag: suspicion toward moralizing prescriptions, paired with a fierce defense of attention, appetite, and aesthetic seriousness. She’s aiming at the modern tendency to turn experience into instruction manuals, including the intellectual’s own tendency to canonize their preferences into doctrine. The “rules” are invalid because aliveness is contingent: it changes with illness, politics, desire, age, grief, art. A static rule can’t keep up with a moving target.
Contextually, this fits a writer who spent a career interrogating how we package experience - from the stylization of suffering to the way interpretation can smother art. The line lands because it offers a compromise that isn’t a compromise: reject certainty, keep the striving. The healthiest posture isn’t arriving at a formula; it’s maintaining the restless, self-correcting pursuit of one.
The subtext is classic Sontag: suspicion toward moralizing prescriptions, paired with a fierce defense of attention, appetite, and aesthetic seriousness. She’s aiming at the modern tendency to turn experience into instruction manuals, including the intellectual’s own tendency to canonize their preferences into doctrine. The “rules” are invalid because aliveness is contingent: it changes with illness, politics, desire, age, grief, art. A static rule can’t keep up with a moving target.
Contextually, this fits a writer who spent a career interrogating how we package experience - from the stylization of suffering to the way interpretation can smother art. The line lands because it offers a compromise that isn’t a compromise: reject certainty, keep the striving. The healthiest posture isn’t arriving at a formula; it’s maintaining the restless, self-correcting pursuit of one.
Quote Details
| Topic | Self-Improvement |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Susan
Add to List








