"America has been another name for opportunity"
About this Quote
Turner’s line flatters the national myth while quietly narrowing what counts as “America.” By making the country “another name for opportunity,” he turns a contested political project into a brand: not a place with laws, conflicts, and exclusions, but a promise. The phrasing is sleek and imperial. “Another name” implies synonym, inevitability, a natural equivalence between a continent and an idea. It’s also a subtle act of erasure: if America equals opportunity, then the people shut out of that opportunity become exceptions, not evidence against the claim.
The context matters. Turner is the frontier historian who argued that American democracy and character were forged at the edge of settlement. His “opportunity” isn’t an abstract ladder of merit; it’s historically tied to land, mobility, and expansion - the ability (for some) to start over because the map kept offering more room. That subtext depends on a disappearing trick: opportunity appears abundant because the costs are externalized onto Indigenous nations, enslaved people, exploited labor, and the environment. The line’s optimism is powered by displacement.
What makes it work rhetorically is its neat conversion of material conditions into moral identity. Opportunity becomes not just something Americans pursue but something America is, granting the nation an alibi: if the country embodies opportunity, then inequality can be cast as personal failure, bad timing, or local corruption rather than structural design. Turner isn’t merely describing a past; he’s underwriting a civic self-image that still sells policies, wars, and nostalgia.
The context matters. Turner is the frontier historian who argued that American democracy and character were forged at the edge of settlement. His “opportunity” isn’t an abstract ladder of merit; it’s historically tied to land, mobility, and expansion - the ability (for some) to start over because the map kept offering more room. That subtext depends on a disappearing trick: opportunity appears abundant because the costs are externalized onto Indigenous nations, enslaved people, exploited labor, and the environment. The line’s optimism is powered by displacement.
What makes it work rhetorically is its neat conversion of material conditions into moral identity. Opportunity becomes not just something Americans pursue but something America is, granting the nation an alibi: if the country embodies opportunity, then inequality can be cast as personal failure, bad timing, or local corruption rather than structural design. Turner isn’t merely describing a past; he’s underwriting a civic self-image that still sells policies, wars, and nostalgia.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Frederick
Add to List



