"America is simultaneously the most attractive and most repulsive place on the planet. It is most loved and most hated"
About this Quote
America as both magnet and menace is a deliberately polarizing frame, and Dinesh D'Souza deploys it like a wedge. The sentence doesn’t argue; it arranges emotions into a neat binary, then dares you to pick which side you’re on. “Most attractive” and “most repulsive” are superlatives doing heavy lifting: they turn a complex, internally varied country into a single, global-scale object that provokes maximum feeling. The effect is less diagnosis than provocation, a way to make ambivalence feel like evidence of importance.
The subtext is that America’s dominance is the explanation for its backlash. If it’s “most hated,” the implication runs, that hatred must be reactive: jealousy, resentment, ideological hostility, or discomfort with American power and culture. That move subtly preempts criticism. Disapproval becomes a sign of America’s centrality rather than a verdict on specific policies, wars, inequalities, or cultural exports. The quote also flatters the audience: to love America is to be clear-eyed enough to withstand the world’s contempt; to defend it is to defend something uniquely consequential.
Context matters because D'Souza’s broader project has often been to reframe critiques of the U.S. (and of American conservatism) as moral panics or partisan distortions. This line functions as a thesis statement for that posture. It packages patriotism with grievance: America is desirable, therefore attacked; attacked, therefore worthy of more ardent loyalty. It’s a clean rhetorical loop, and like most clean loops, it leaves the mess offstage.
The subtext is that America’s dominance is the explanation for its backlash. If it’s “most hated,” the implication runs, that hatred must be reactive: jealousy, resentment, ideological hostility, or discomfort with American power and culture. That move subtly preempts criticism. Disapproval becomes a sign of America’s centrality rather than a verdict on specific policies, wars, inequalities, or cultural exports. The quote also flatters the audience: to love America is to be clear-eyed enough to withstand the world’s contempt; to defend it is to defend something uniquely consequential.
Context matters because D'Souza’s broader project has often been to reframe critiques of the U.S. (and of American conservatism) as moral panics or partisan distortions. This line functions as a thesis statement for that posture. It packages patriotism with grievance: America is desirable, therefore attacked; attacked, therefore worthy of more ardent loyalty. It’s a clean rhetorical loop, and like most clean loops, it leaves the mess offstage.
Quote Details
| Topic | Deep |
|---|
More Quotes by Dinesh
Add to List
