"America may be unique in being a country which has leapt from barbarism to decadence without touching civilization"
About this Quote
O'Hara lands the insult like a martini glass on a marble floor: clean, loud, and impossible to ignore. The line weaponizes an old civilizational ladder - barbarism, civilization, decadence - and then yanks out the middle rung. It's not just that America is decadent; it's that it got there without earning the cultural infrastructure that decadence is supposed to corrupt. Decadence, in this framing, isn’t merely moral rot. It’s a luxury problem, the late-stage indulgence of societies that once built cathedrals, codes, and canons. O'Hara suggests America raced to the cushioned seat without taking the hard, forming journey.
The subtext is class anxiety wearing a national costume. O'Hara, a novelist obsessed with status rituals and the cruelty of social gradations, is really talking about taste: the brittle distinction between money and refinement, between success and cultivation. "Barbarism" isn't loincloths; it's a young country's rawness, its suspicion of elites, its preference for hustle over heritage. "Civilization" stands for continuity and restraint - institutions, manners, a shared sense of what should not be for sale. Skipping it means the market gets to define everything, including virtue.
Context matters: O'Hara wrote in a 20th-century America flush with mass prosperity, advertising, and upward mobility. The line reads like a rebuke to a nation that industrialized faster than it educated itself, turning freedom into appetite and equality into sameness. It's cruel, but it's precise: a culture can become rich and bored before it becomes wise.
The subtext is class anxiety wearing a national costume. O'Hara, a novelist obsessed with status rituals and the cruelty of social gradations, is really talking about taste: the brittle distinction between money and refinement, between success and cultivation. "Barbarism" isn't loincloths; it's a young country's rawness, its suspicion of elites, its preference for hustle over heritage. "Civilization" stands for continuity and restraint - institutions, manners, a shared sense of what should not be for sale. Skipping it means the market gets to define everything, including virtue.
Context matters: O'Hara wrote in a 20th-century America flush with mass prosperity, advertising, and upward mobility. The line reads like a rebuke to a nation that industrialized faster than it educated itself, turning freedom into appetite and equality into sameness. It's cruel, but it's precise: a culture can become rich and bored before it becomes wise.
Quote Details
| Topic | Sarcastic |
|---|
More Quotes by John
Add to List
