"America wasn't founded so that we could all be better. America was founded so we could all be anything we damned well pleased"
About this Quote
O'Rourke’s genius here is the bait-and-switch: he starts with the uplifting civic religion of national “betterment” and then yanks the hymnbook away. The line refuses the idea of America as a moral improvement project. Instead, it frames the country as a permissive machine for self-invention, powered less by virtue than by choice and appetite. The profanity-adjacent cadence of “damned well pleased” isn’t just seasoning; it’s the point. It makes liberty sound like a lived, slightly messy practice, not a marble statue.
The intent is corrective and combative. O'Rourke is pushing back on reformers, scolds, and ideologues who treat the United States as a classroom where the population needs to be disciplined into righteousness. His subtext is that a lot of political rhetoric uses “better” as a velvet glove for control: who decides what “better” means, and who gets punished until they comply? By contrast, “anything” smuggles in a bracing, uncomfortable pluralism. It’s not “anything noble,” not “anything productive,” not even “anything wise.” It’s maximal freedom, with all the weirdness and vice that implies.
Context matters: O’Rourke wrote across decades when culture-war moralism and policy paternalism kept resurging on left and right. The quote functions as a libertarian punchline with teeth, elevating the Founding as a license for experimentation rather than a mandate for collective uplift. It’s funny because it’s harsh. It’s persuasive because it admits the part polite patriotism often edits out: freedom includes people you don’t approve of, doing things you’d never choose.
The intent is corrective and combative. O'Rourke is pushing back on reformers, scolds, and ideologues who treat the United States as a classroom where the population needs to be disciplined into righteousness. His subtext is that a lot of political rhetoric uses “better” as a velvet glove for control: who decides what “better” means, and who gets punished until they comply? By contrast, “anything” smuggles in a bracing, uncomfortable pluralism. It’s not “anything noble,” not “anything productive,” not even “anything wise.” It’s maximal freedom, with all the weirdness and vice that implies.
Context matters: O’Rourke wrote across decades when culture-war moralism and policy paternalism kept resurging on left and right. The quote functions as a libertarian punchline with teeth, elevating the Founding as a license for experimentation rather than a mandate for collective uplift. It’s funny because it’s harsh. It’s persuasive because it admits the part polite patriotism often edits out: freedom includes people you don’t approve of, doing things you’d never choose.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by J. O'Rourke
Add to List








