"Americans seem sometimes to believe that if you are a thinker you must be a frowning bore, because thinking is so damn serious"
About this Quote
Maritain is skewering a peculiarly American suspicion: the idea that intellect must come packaged with grimness, as if seriousness were the only moral credential a mind can wear in public. His barb lands because it exposes a double bind in U.S. culture. We celebrate “innovation” and “big ideas,” yet often distrust the figure who actually thinks in a sustained, disciplined way. The thinker is tolerated when he performs as a technocrat, an entertainer, or a pundit; he becomes suspect when thinking looks like its own calling.
The line’s bite comes from its caricature of the “frowning bore,” a stock character that lets a culture dodge the inconvenience of being challenged. If thought is framed as “so damn serious,” it becomes easy to treat philosophy as either joyless elitism or sanctimony. Maritain flips that script: he implies that the pose of solemnity is not proof of depth but often a kind of theater - a way to claim authority by looking pained.
Context matters. Maritain, a French Catholic philosopher who spent time in the United States during the mid-20th century, arrived from an intellectual world where public seriousness could coexist with wit, art, and even pleasure. In America, he’s observing both anti-intellectual reflexes and a Protestant-tinged earnestness that mistakes dourness for virtue. The subtext is a defense of humane intelligence: thinking can be rigorous without being humorless, and the healthiest public mind is one that can argue, doubt, and still laugh.
The line’s bite comes from its caricature of the “frowning bore,” a stock character that lets a culture dodge the inconvenience of being challenged. If thought is framed as “so damn serious,” it becomes easy to treat philosophy as either joyless elitism or sanctimony. Maritain flips that script: he implies that the pose of solemnity is not proof of depth but often a kind of theater - a way to claim authority by looking pained.
Context matters. Maritain, a French Catholic philosopher who spent time in the United States during the mid-20th century, arrived from an intellectual world where public seriousness could coexist with wit, art, and even pleasure. In America, he’s observing both anti-intellectual reflexes and a Protestant-tinged earnestness that mistakes dourness for virtue. The subtext is a defense of humane intelligence: thinking can be rigorous without being humorless, and the healthiest public mind is one that can argue, doubt, and still laugh.
Quote Details
| Topic | Deep |
|---|
More Quotes by Jacques
Add to List






