"America's state religion, is patriotism, a phenomenon which has convinced many of the citizenry that "treason" is morally worse than murder or rape"
About this Quote
Blum’s line is engineered to sound like a diagnosis, not a provocation: “state religion” frames patriotism as an orthodoxy with rituals, taboos, and heresy hunts. It’s a deliberate inversion of America’s self-image as secular and freedom-loving. By borrowing religious language, he implies that loyalty to the nation operates less as a civic virtue than as a faith that demands emotional submission, especially in moments of conflict.
The sting is in his moral comparison. Treason versus “murder or rape” is not a casual escalation; it forces the reader to notice how national-security discourse reorders ethics. Violent crimes harm bodies; “treason” harms the state’s story about itself. Blum’s subtext is that the U.S. political culture often treats the latter as the unforgivable sin because it threatens legitimacy, power, and cohesion. That’s why whistleblowers, dissenters, and defectors can be painted as monsters more readily than perpetrators of interpersonal violence, particularly when the accused is linked to foreign enemies. The quote isn’t arguing that murder is excusable; it’s arguing that the state’s outrage is selective, and selection reveals priorities.
Context matters: Blum built a career cataloging U.S. covert operations and interventions, and he wrote from the long shadow of the Cold War, when “un-American” functioned as a civic excommunication. Post-9/11 politics made his framing newly legible: security language expands, loyalty tests proliferate, and “patriotism” becomes a shortcut to end debate. The intent is to unmask that shortcut as a moral shortcut, too.
The sting is in his moral comparison. Treason versus “murder or rape” is not a casual escalation; it forces the reader to notice how national-security discourse reorders ethics. Violent crimes harm bodies; “treason” harms the state’s story about itself. Blum’s subtext is that the U.S. political culture often treats the latter as the unforgivable sin because it threatens legitimacy, power, and cohesion. That’s why whistleblowers, dissenters, and defectors can be painted as monsters more readily than perpetrators of interpersonal violence, particularly when the accused is linked to foreign enemies. The quote isn’t arguing that murder is excusable; it’s arguing that the state’s outrage is selective, and selection reveals priorities.
Context matters: Blum built a career cataloging U.S. covert operations and interventions, and he wrote from the long shadow of the Cold War, when “un-American” functioned as a civic excommunication. Post-9/11 politics made his framing newly legible: security language expands, loyalty tests proliferate, and “patriotism” becomes a shortcut to end debate. The intent is to unmask that shortcut as a moral shortcut, too.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by William
Add to List
