"An influential member of parliament has not only to pay much money to become such, and to give time and labour, he has also to sacrifice his mind too - at least all the characteristics part of it that which is original and most his own"
About this Quote
Power in a modern parliament, Bagehot insists, is a kind of gilded lobotomy. The line lands because it refuses the usual Victorian pieties about public service. Yes, an MP pays in cash, time, and effort; that’s the respectable part of the bill. The real cost is psychic: to become “influential” you must sand down the mind until it stops catching on the grain of party discipline, procedure, and consensus. Influence, in his account, is less the reward for independent thought than the prize for demonstrating you can suppress it on command.
Bagehot’s intent is diagnostic, not merely cynical. Writing in the age of expanding suffrage and increasingly organized party machinery, he understood Parliament as an institution that converts private judgment into public legibility. Originality is risky because it is unpredictable; politics runs on predictability. The subtext is brutal: the system doesn’t just tolerate conformity, it selects for it. “All the characteristics... that which is original and most his own” reads like a lament for the inner life that can’t survive the whip system, the backroom bargain, the careful ambiguity required to stay acceptable to donors, colleagues, and the press.
What makes the sentence work is its quiet escalation. Money, “time and labour” are tangible sacrifices; “mind” is intimate. Bagehot turns influence into a moral compromise you can’t expense away. It’s also an early sketch of a problem that feels contemporary: institutions that claim to value “bold ideas” while rewarding those who can translate themselves into safe, repeatable talking points.
Bagehot’s intent is diagnostic, not merely cynical. Writing in the age of expanding suffrage and increasingly organized party machinery, he understood Parliament as an institution that converts private judgment into public legibility. Originality is risky because it is unpredictable; politics runs on predictability. The subtext is brutal: the system doesn’t just tolerate conformity, it selects for it. “All the characteristics... that which is original and most his own” reads like a lament for the inner life that can’t survive the whip system, the backroom bargain, the careful ambiguity required to stay acceptable to donors, colleagues, and the press.
What makes the sentence work is its quiet escalation. Money, “time and labour” are tangible sacrifices; “mind” is intimate. Bagehot turns influence into a moral compromise you can’t expense away. It’s also an early sketch of a problem that feels contemporary: institutions that claim to value “bold ideas” while rewarding those who can translate themselves into safe, repeatable talking points.
Quote Details
| Topic | Leadership |
|---|
More Quotes by Walter
Add to List





