"An intelligent and conscientious opposition is a part of loyalty to country"
About this Quote
Patriotism, Colby suggests, is not applause but friction. In one sentence he reframes “loyalty” as something sturdier than consent: a civic posture willing to irritate power for the country’s long-term health. The key move is the pairing of “intelligent” and “conscientious” with “opposition.” He’s not romanticizing contrarianism or street-corner cynicism; he’s staking out a middle zone between sabotage and submission. Opposition earns legitimacy when it’s informed (intelligent) and morally awake (conscientious), aimed at correcting the state rather than humiliating it.
The subtext is a warning against a familiar political scam: that dissent equals disloyalty. That charge is especially potent in moments of crisis, when leaders, parties, or movements demand unity as a substitute for accountability. Colby’s phrasing implies that real loyalty is measured by what you’re willing to risk - reputationally, politically - to keep the nation from confusing its government with its ideals. He makes “opposition” sound like a civic duty, not a personality type.
Contextually, Colby sits in early 20th-century American governance, an era of war, Red Scares, and the expansion of federal power, when “100 percent Americanism” often meant policing speech and narrowing the definition of belonging. His line reads like a bureaucrat’s antidote to wartime fever: a reminder that democracies don’t collapse only through external enemies, but through internal habits of obedience. Intelligent opposition becomes a maintenance function - the country’s immune system, not its infection.
The subtext is a warning against a familiar political scam: that dissent equals disloyalty. That charge is especially potent in moments of crisis, when leaders, parties, or movements demand unity as a substitute for accountability. Colby’s phrasing implies that real loyalty is measured by what you’re willing to risk - reputationally, politically - to keep the nation from confusing its government with its ideals. He makes “opposition” sound like a civic duty, not a personality type.
Contextually, Colby sits in early 20th-century American governance, an era of war, Red Scares, and the expansion of federal power, when “100 percent Americanism” often meant policing speech and narrowing the definition of belonging. His line reads like a bureaucrat’s antidote to wartime fever: a reminder that democracies don’t collapse only through external enemies, but through internal habits of obedience. Intelligent opposition becomes a maintenance function - the country’s immune system, not its infection.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Bainbridge
Add to List
