"And, I hope now that everybody understands that the Labour Party - as it always has done - stands for free speech and individual Members of the Labour Party are entitled to exercise that free speech"
About this Quote
The sentence is doing two jobs at once: laundering a party reputation while quietly shrinking the blast radius of whatever controversy just detonated. Ron Davies frames Labour as an institution of principle - "as it always has done" is the key bit of stagecraft. It’s not evidence, it’s inoculation: an appeal to tradition that asks listeners to stop questioning the present by wrapping it in a comforting past.
Then comes the careful split-screen: the Labour Party "stands for" free speech, and "individual Members" are "entitled" to exercise it. That distinction matters. It’s a way to defend a colleague (or himself) without fully owning the content of what was said. The party can claim the glow of liberal virtue while pushing the risk down to the level of the individual, where responsibility can be isolated and, if needed, disavowed. It’s classic political damage control disguised as constitutional principle.
The phrasing also signals that free speech here is being invoked as a shield, not a debate invitation. "I hope now that everybody understands" carries a faint reprimand, a suggestion that criticism is a failure of comprehension rather than a legitimate disagreement. It tries to move the argument from ethics to procedure: not "Was this right?" but "Are we allowed to say it?"
Contextually, it fits a moment when parties manage internal dissent under media pressure: assert a big value, affirm member autonomy, imply the story should end. The subtext is simple: stop asking Labour to police its own, and stop asking Davies to apologize.
Then comes the careful split-screen: the Labour Party "stands for" free speech, and "individual Members" are "entitled" to exercise it. That distinction matters. It’s a way to defend a colleague (or himself) without fully owning the content of what was said. The party can claim the glow of liberal virtue while pushing the risk down to the level of the individual, where responsibility can be isolated and, if needed, disavowed. It’s classic political damage control disguised as constitutional principle.
The phrasing also signals that free speech here is being invoked as a shield, not a debate invitation. "I hope now that everybody understands" carries a faint reprimand, a suggestion that criticism is a failure of comprehension rather than a legitimate disagreement. It tries to move the argument from ethics to procedure: not "Was this right?" but "Are we allowed to say it?"
Contextually, it fits a moment when parties manage internal dissent under media pressure: assert a big value, affirm member autonomy, imply the story should end. The subtext is simple: stop asking Labour to police its own, and stop asking Davies to apologize.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Ron
Add to List