"And remember, where you have a concentration of power in a few hands, all too frequently men with the mentality of gangsters get control. History has proven that"
About this Quote
Acton’s line lands like a polite Victorian sentence with a switchblade inside. He isn’t merely warning that power can corrupt; he’s insisting that power attracts a certain type. The “mentality of gangsters” is doing deliberate work here: it collapses the distance between respectable governance and organized crime, implying that the difference is often costume, not character. Acton’s target is concentration itself - the structural conditions that invite predation - not the occasional bad ruler.
The subtext is a bleak theory of selection. Systems that bottleneck authority into “a few hands” reward ruthlessness, secrecy, and loyalty tests. In that environment, moral restraint reads as weakness, while intimidation and deal-making read as competence. Acton’s phrasing, “all too frequently,” is the historian’s scalpel: he’s not claiming inevitability (which would sound theological), but a recurring pattern that should terrify any adult who’s read a little.
Context matters. Acton lived through a century of expanding state capacity, revolutions, empire, and the tightening embrace of bureaucracy. He was a liberal Catholic and a fierce critic of absolutism; his broader project was to judge institutions by how they limit human sin, not by how noble their slogans are. “History has proven that” is the final rhetorical shove - an appeal to evidence over optimism, to the record over the romance. He’s telling you to stop being surprised when concentrated power starts acting like a racket, because history’s been running the same experiment for centuries, and the results keep coming back ugly.
The subtext is a bleak theory of selection. Systems that bottleneck authority into “a few hands” reward ruthlessness, secrecy, and loyalty tests. In that environment, moral restraint reads as weakness, while intimidation and deal-making read as competence. Acton’s phrasing, “all too frequently,” is the historian’s scalpel: he’s not claiming inevitability (which would sound theological), but a recurring pattern that should terrify any adult who’s read a little.
Context matters. Acton lived through a century of expanding state capacity, revolutions, empire, and the tightening embrace of bureaucracy. He was a liberal Catholic and a fierce critic of absolutism; his broader project was to judge institutions by how they limit human sin, not by how noble their slogans are. “History has proven that” is the final rhetorical shove - an appeal to evidence over optimism, to the record over the romance. He’s telling you to stop being surprised when concentrated power starts acting like a racket, because history’s been running the same experiment for centuries, and the results keep coming back ugly.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Lord
Add to List







