"And you can't make a mistake when you are reading the Torah, so you have men standing around who will correct you if you are reading it incorrectly"
About this Quote
What Gertz gets at, almost offhandedly, is how a religious text can function less like private inspiration and more like a live, communal performance with rules. The line is structured around a blunt claim - “you can’t make a mistake” - and then immediately grounds that absolutism in a practical image: men literally “standing around” to correct you. It’s an unglamorous tableau, which is why it lands. Judaism here isn’t presented as vague spirituality; it’s embodied, supervised, and audible.
The intent feels explanatory, even a bit awed: she’s pointing to a culture where precision matters because the Torah isn’t treated as a flexible prompt. Reading becomes a responsibility. The subtext, though, is about authority and belonging. Correction can be care (protecting the integrity of the text, helping a reader honor tradition), but it can also be policing. The detail that it’s “men” standing around quietly signals gendered gatekeeping without explicitly arguing it. You hear the social architecture: who gets to read, who gets to correct, who is assumed to be watched.
In a pop-figure voice, the quote also reads like a bridge-building move. Gertz translates an insider practice for outsiders by framing it in everyday terms: you’re not alone up there, and accuracy is communal business. The cultural moment underneath is familiar: in an age of personal branding and “my truth,” she’s describing a system designed to resist improvisation. That tension - warmth of community versus strictness of oversight - is the real charge in the sentence.
The intent feels explanatory, even a bit awed: she’s pointing to a culture where precision matters because the Torah isn’t treated as a flexible prompt. Reading becomes a responsibility. The subtext, though, is about authority and belonging. Correction can be care (protecting the integrity of the text, helping a reader honor tradition), but it can also be policing. The detail that it’s “men” standing around quietly signals gendered gatekeeping without explicitly arguing it. You hear the social architecture: who gets to read, who gets to correct, who is assumed to be watched.
In a pop-figure voice, the quote also reads like a bridge-building move. Gertz translates an insider practice for outsiders by framing it in everyday terms: you’re not alone up there, and accuracy is communal business. The cultural moment underneath is familiar: in an age of personal branding and “my truth,” she’s describing a system designed to resist improvisation. That tension - warmth of community versus strictness of oversight - is the real charge in the sentence.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|
More Quotes by Jami
Add to List
