"Any truth is better than indefinite doubt"
About this Quote
Arthur Conan Doyle puts a simple, bracing idea at the center of both detective work and human psychology: certainty, even when painful, is kinder than the corrosive haze of not knowing. Voiced by Sherlock Holmes in The Adventure of the Yellow Face, the line arrives as counsel to a husband tormented by suspicion about his wife. Holmes urges him toward disclosure, not because truth is always pleasant, but because indecision multiplies suffering. Doubt feeds imagination; it inflates shadows into monsters. Truth, by contrast, sets a boundary to fear. One can mourn, forgive, plan, or change course. One can act.
The phrasing matters. Any truth does not exalt truth as inherently pleasant; it admits that some truths are bleak. The critical contrast is with indefinite doubt, the limbo without edges or timeline, the unresolved state that erodes trust, sleep, and judgment. Doyle had trained as a physician, and the clinical logic shows: a clear diagnosis, even of a grave illness, lets treatment begin. In narrative terms, too, detective fiction promises release from uncertainty; the final reveal is not merely spectacle but relief.
There is also a moral dimension. Uncertainty tempts us toward self-protective fantasies and accusatory narratives about others. In The Adventure of the Yellow Face, Holmes himself learns humility when the truth confounds his expectation and calls for compassion. Transparency becomes not only an epistemic value but an ethical one, a way to restore dignity to all involved.
Modern life offers countless echoes: awaiting a medical test, refreshing a job application portal, sensing a rift in a friendship. The mind rushes to fill gaps with worst-case scenarios. The remedy is not wishful thinking but inquiry, conversation, evidence. Acceptance of truth does not erase pain, but it replaces the shapeless dread of what-ifs with the workable reality of what is. From there, agency returns. That is the heart of Doyle’s insight: clarity is a form of mercy.
The phrasing matters. Any truth does not exalt truth as inherently pleasant; it admits that some truths are bleak. The critical contrast is with indefinite doubt, the limbo without edges or timeline, the unresolved state that erodes trust, sleep, and judgment. Doyle had trained as a physician, and the clinical logic shows: a clear diagnosis, even of a grave illness, lets treatment begin. In narrative terms, too, detective fiction promises release from uncertainty; the final reveal is not merely spectacle but relief.
There is also a moral dimension. Uncertainty tempts us toward self-protective fantasies and accusatory narratives about others. In The Adventure of the Yellow Face, Holmes himself learns humility when the truth confounds his expectation and calls for compassion. Transparency becomes not only an epistemic value but an ethical one, a way to restore dignity to all involved.
Modern life offers countless echoes: awaiting a medical test, refreshing a job application portal, sensing a rift in a friendship. The mind rushes to fill gaps with worst-case scenarios. The remedy is not wishful thinking but inquiry, conversation, evidence. Acceptance of truth does not erase pain, but it replaces the shapeless dread of what-ifs with the workable reality of what is. From there, agency returns. That is the heart of Doyle’s insight: clarity is a form of mercy.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|
More Quotes by Arthur
Add to List












