"Anyone who isn't confused really doesn't understand the situation"
About this Quote
Murrow’s line doesn’t comfort; it indicts. In one clean inversion, he flips the usual expectation that clarity equals competence. If you’re not confused, he suggests, you’re not informed enough to grasp how tangled the facts are, how compromised the institutions might be, how much propaganda and self-interest are contaminating the signal. It’s a journalist’s jab at false certainty, delivered with the dry bite of someone who has watched public life reward simple stories over accurate ones.
The intent is both diagnostic and ethical. Murrow isn’t praising confusion as a lifestyle; he’s naming it as an honest symptom of reality when reality is messy. The subtext: beware the pundit, official, or neighbor who has a neat answer too quickly. Confidence can be a performance, especially in moments when governments sell wars, corporations sell reassurance, or broadcasters sell coherence. Confusion becomes a kind of moral intelligence: the willingness to sit with contradictory evidence instead of snapping it into ideology.
Context matters because Murrow worked in an era when mass media was consolidating its power and the stakes of narrative were national. From World War II reporting to the Cold War’s atmosphere of suspicion and spectacle, he saw how easily public consensus could be engineered. The line also doubles as a quiet defense of serious reporting: if journalism is doing its job, it won’t always leave audiences soothed. Sometimes the most truthful feeling is disorientation, because it means you’re seeing the whole board, not just the talking points.
The intent is both diagnostic and ethical. Murrow isn’t praising confusion as a lifestyle; he’s naming it as an honest symptom of reality when reality is messy. The subtext: beware the pundit, official, or neighbor who has a neat answer too quickly. Confidence can be a performance, especially in moments when governments sell wars, corporations sell reassurance, or broadcasters sell coherence. Confusion becomes a kind of moral intelligence: the willingness to sit with contradictory evidence instead of snapping it into ideology.
Context matters because Murrow worked in an era when mass media was consolidating its power and the stakes of narrative were national. From World War II reporting to the Cold War’s atmosphere of suspicion and spectacle, he saw how easily public consensus could be engineered. The line also doubles as a quiet defense of serious reporting: if journalism is doing its job, it won’t always leave audiences soothed. Sometimes the most truthful feeling is disorientation, because it means you’re seeing the whole board, not just the talking points.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Later attribution: Wartime Style (Lora Ann Sigler, 2022) modern compilationISBN: 9781476648408 · ID: OmiYEAAAQBAJ
Evidence: ... Anyone who isn't confused really doesn't understand the situation.” —Edward R. Murrow, newscaster. Napalm. in. the. Morning. How do fashions, fads, or trends, come about? Against what background do peo- ple seize upon a certain way of doing ... Other candidates (1) Edward R. Murrow (Edward R. Murrow) compilation88.9% ime 1969 anyone who isnt confused doesnt really understand the situation as quot |
More Quotes by Edward
Add to List







