"Anyway, so here I was caught between Johnson on the one side, who was my leader, I was his whip, and here was my dear friend, personal friend, Kennedy, and they're going to go into my state and ruin it. What am I going to do?"
About this Quote
Loyalty, in this telling, isn’t a virtue; it’s a trap with two smiling faces. Smathers sketches a scene that’s almost comically intimate for politics: “my leader” Lyndon Johnson on one side, “my dear friend” Kennedy on the other, both poised to “go into my state and ruin it.” The line works because it strips away the civic pageantry and replaces it with the cramped geometry of power. This isn’t an ideological crisis. It’s a territorial one.
The subtext is pure mid-century Democratic knife work. As a Senate whip, Smathers is supposed to be Johnson’s enforcer and numbers-guy, a role built on discipline and reciprocity. But the Kennedys represented a competing center of gravity: glamour, money, and a national machine that didn’t always ask permission of Southern power brokers. “My state” isn’t just Florida as a place; it’s a fiefdom, a coalition, a career. When he says they’ll “ruin it,” he’s admitting that high-level alliances can be locally catastrophic: endorsements, visits, and rival factions can scramble a state party, threaten donors, and invite primary challenges.
The rhetorical question, “What am I going to do?” is the real reveal. It signals that the options are all reputational losses: betray the boss, betray the friend, or pretend neutrality while everyone notices you flinching. Smathers isn’t asking for advice; he’s performing the helplessness that lets a politician choose a side while claiming he had no choice at all.
The subtext is pure mid-century Democratic knife work. As a Senate whip, Smathers is supposed to be Johnson’s enforcer and numbers-guy, a role built on discipline and reciprocity. But the Kennedys represented a competing center of gravity: glamour, money, and a national machine that didn’t always ask permission of Southern power brokers. “My state” isn’t just Florida as a place; it’s a fiefdom, a coalition, a career. When he says they’ll “ruin it,” he’s admitting that high-level alliances can be locally catastrophic: endorsements, visits, and rival factions can scramble a state party, threaten donors, and invite primary challenges.
The rhetorical question, “What am I going to do?” is the real reveal. It signals that the options are all reputational losses: betray the boss, betray the friend, or pretend neutrality while everyone notices you flinching. Smathers isn’t asking for advice; he’s performing the helplessness that lets a politician choose a side while claiming he had no choice at all.
Quote Details
| Topic | Decision-Making |
|---|
More Quotes by George
Add to List
