"Apathy can be overcome by enthusiasm, and enthusiasm can only be aroused by two things: first, an ideal, with takes the imagination by storm, and second, a definite intelligible plan for carrying that ideal into practice"
About this Quote
Toynbee is writing like a historian who’s watched civilizations die of boredom. The line has the clipped certainty of someone tired of grand rhetoric that goes nowhere: apathy isn’t beaten by scolding or facts, but by a felt charge. And that charge, he insists, has a strict recipe. Not vibes. Not “engagement.” Two ingredients: a storm-taking ideal and a plan you can actually follow.
The subtext is a rebuke to two familiar failure modes of modern politics and public life. First, the technocrat’s fantasy that if you show people the spreadsheet, they’ll care. Toynbee flips it: enthusiasm is not a data problem; it’s an imagination problem. Second, the romantic’s fantasy that if you give people a beautiful slogan, they’ll march indefinitely. He won’t grant that either. Ideals without operational steps curdle into spectacle, factionalism, or fatigue.
Context matters. Toynbee’s career is a long meditation on how societies respond to crisis - his “challenge and response” framework assumes decline isn’t inevitable, but inertia is. Postwar Europe, mass politics, propaganda, and the rise of planned economies all haunt this sentence. He’s describing how collective energy gets mobilized, and quietly warning how easily it can be misdirected: “imagination by storm” is also how demagogues recruit.
What makes the quote work is its unsentimental psychology. It respects people enough to admit they won’t move without meaning, and it respects reality enough to say meaning won’t survive without method. That’s not inspiration; it’s a blueprint for turning belief into durable action.
The subtext is a rebuke to two familiar failure modes of modern politics and public life. First, the technocrat’s fantasy that if you show people the spreadsheet, they’ll care. Toynbee flips it: enthusiasm is not a data problem; it’s an imagination problem. Second, the romantic’s fantasy that if you give people a beautiful slogan, they’ll march indefinitely. He won’t grant that either. Ideals without operational steps curdle into spectacle, factionalism, or fatigue.
Context matters. Toynbee’s career is a long meditation on how societies respond to crisis - his “challenge and response” framework assumes decline isn’t inevitable, but inertia is. Postwar Europe, mass politics, propaganda, and the rise of planned economies all haunt this sentence. He’s describing how collective energy gets mobilized, and quietly warning how easily it can be misdirected: “imagination by storm” is also how demagogues recruit.
What makes the quote work is its unsentimental psychology. It respects people enough to admit they won’t move without meaning, and it respects reality enough to say meaning won’t survive without method. That’s not inspiration; it’s a blueprint for turning belief into durable action.
Quote Details
| Topic | Vision & Strategy |
|---|
More Quotes by Arnold
Add to List
