"Are you saying we shouldn't be prepared? And I'm asking you that right now, Daniel. ... Why would you be against people being able not only to be prepared to have food and water for their friends, but to defend themselves from looters and some of these degradation of society that happen in these crises?"
About this Quote
The quote’s intent is to launder a harder argument (armed readiness, vigilant self-defense, a permission structure for violence) through the soft-focus language of mutual aid. "For their friends" functions like a moral shield, positioning stockpiling and arming not as individual paranoia but as community service. Then the turn: "looters" and "degradation of society". Those phrases are doing cultural work far beyond their dictionary definitions. They summon a familiar crisis narrative in American politics: disaster as a moment when the social contract collapses, outsiders swarm, and force becomes the only reliable currency.
Subtextually, Shea is asking the audience to accept a bleak premise: that institutions can’t be trusted in emergencies, and that citizenship is proven by the capacity to defend property and people with weapons. It’s an argument designed to feel like realism while quietly radicalizing what "preparedness" means. The context likely sits in the post-Katrina, post-pandemic, post-urban-unrest ecosystem where images of chaos travel faster than data, and "looters" becomes a coded shorthand for whose lives are presumed threatening when scarcity hits. The rhetorical trick is simple and effective: redefine fear as responsibility, then dare anyone to disagree.
Quote Details
| Topic | Resilience |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Shea, Matt. (2026, February 9). Are you saying we shouldn't be prepared? And I'm asking you that right now, Daniel. ... Why would you be against people being able not only to be prepared to have food and water for their friends, but to defend themselves from looters and some of these degradation of society that happen in these crises? FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/are-you-saying-we-shouldnt-be-prepared-and-im-185014/
Chicago Style
Shea, Matt. "Are you saying we shouldn't be prepared? And I'm asking you that right now, Daniel. ... Why would you be against people being able not only to be prepared to have food and water for their friends, but to defend themselves from looters and some of these degradation of society that happen in these crises?" FixQuotes. February 9, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/are-you-saying-we-shouldnt-be-prepared-and-im-185014/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"Are you saying we shouldn't be prepared? And I'm asking you that right now, Daniel. ... Why would you be against people being able not only to be prepared to have food and water for their friends, but to defend themselves from looters and some of these degradation of society that happen in these crises?" FixQuotes, 9 Feb. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/are-you-saying-we-shouldnt-be-prepared-and-im-185014/. Accessed 11 Feb. 2026.





