"Art never improves, but... the material of art is never quite the same"
About this Quote
Eliot’s line is a tidy provocation dressed as a shrug: progress is a myth, yet change is unavoidable. “Art never improves” needles the comfy Victorian story that culture is a staircase climbing toward refinement. Eliot, the modernist who built cathedrals out of fragments, is too skeptical for that. He’s saying the great works don’t get “better” the way engines do. Homer doesn’t become obsolete because someone later learned a new trick with metaphor.
Then comes the twist that saves the sentence from pure curmudgeonry: “the material of art is never quite the same.” Art may not improve, but its raw ingredients mutate. Not just paint, ink, or instruments, but the whole mental weather: the language as it’s spoken, the shared references, the spiritual and political anxieties, the pace of the city, the shock of new media. A poet inherits not a blank page but a crowded room. Every new work is made out of altered conditions and altered readers.
The subtext is Eliot’s larger obsession with tradition as a living pressure, not a museum. He argued that the present rewrites the past even as it borrows from it; “material” includes the entire back-catalog of art itself, now rearranged by what came after. In the postwar, post-empire churn of his lifetime, this becomes both warning and permission: don’t chase novelty as moral superiority, but don’t pretend you can make the Iliad again. You get different air. You make different fire.
Then comes the twist that saves the sentence from pure curmudgeonry: “the material of art is never quite the same.” Art may not improve, but its raw ingredients mutate. Not just paint, ink, or instruments, but the whole mental weather: the language as it’s spoken, the shared references, the spiritual and political anxieties, the pace of the city, the shock of new media. A poet inherits not a blank page but a crowded room. Every new work is made out of altered conditions and altered readers.
The subtext is Eliot’s larger obsession with tradition as a living pressure, not a museum. He argued that the present rewrites the past even as it borrows from it; “material” includes the entire back-catalog of art itself, now rearranged by what came after. In the postwar, post-empire churn of his lifetime, this becomes both warning and permission: don’t chase novelty as moral superiority, but don’t pretend you can make the Iliad again. You get different air. You make different fire.
Quote Details
| Topic | Art |
|---|
More Quotes by S. Eliot
Add to List










