"Artists themselves are not confined, but their output is"
About this Quote
Smithson’s line lands like a cool rebuke to the romantic fantasy of the artist as permanently unbound. He grants the maker a kind of conceptual freedom, then immediately clips the wings of the thing we actually encounter: the work. However expansive an artist’s thinking may be, the output is forced to take a form, enter a system, become an object, a document, a commodity, a photograph, a caption. In other words: the artist can roam; the art gets processed.
The subtext is institutional and mildly sardonic. “Confined” doesn’t just mean physically limited; it points to the invisible architecture around art-making: gallery walls, transport crates, insurance forms, conservation standards, zoning laws, even the frame of a camera. Smithson was obsessed with entropy and site-specificity, and his own practice makes the point. The Spiral Jetty is, in a sense, “unconfined” out in the Great Salt Lake, yet what most people know is its mediated afterlife: film stills, essays, museum screenings, art-history canonization. The work circulates precisely because it is reduced, packaged, and legible.
The intent, then, is not to celebrate freedom but to diagnose a trap: the more radical the gesture, the more urgently the culture tries to stabilize it. Output must be narratable and ownable to travel. Smithson’s phrase is a compact warning about how institutions domesticate volatility - and an admission that even artists who flee the white cube still leave behind something the white cube can eventually hang.
The subtext is institutional and mildly sardonic. “Confined” doesn’t just mean physically limited; it points to the invisible architecture around art-making: gallery walls, transport crates, insurance forms, conservation standards, zoning laws, even the frame of a camera. Smithson was obsessed with entropy and site-specificity, and his own practice makes the point. The Spiral Jetty is, in a sense, “unconfined” out in the Great Salt Lake, yet what most people know is its mediated afterlife: film stills, essays, museum screenings, art-history canonization. The work circulates precisely because it is reduced, packaged, and legible.
The intent, then, is not to celebrate freedom but to diagnose a trap: the more radical the gesture, the more urgently the culture tries to stabilize it. Output must be narratable and ownable to travel. Smithson’s phrase is a compact warning about how institutions domesticate volatility - and an admission that even artists who flee the white cube still leave behind something the white cube can eventually hang.
Quote Details
| Topic | Art |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List
