"As far as advice to potential teenage idols, there is no formula"
About this Quote
“As far as advice to potential teenage idols, there is no formula” lands like a shrug, but it’s really a quiet act of self-defense from someone who lived inside a machine that pretended to run on certainty. Bobby Sherman wasn’t just a singer; he was a 60s/70s teen-magazine ecosystem: pinups, TV appearances, carefully managed charm, a career built on seeming effortlessly lovable. The subtext is that the effort was never effortless, and the people selling it had every incentive to claim they’d cracked the code.
Sherman’s phrasing does two things at once. “As far as advice” narrows his authority on purpose, dodging the guru role that aging pop figures are pushed into. And “no formula” punctures the fantasy that fame is a meritocratic recipe - rehearse, smile, be wholesome, repeat - when the real determinants are timing, industry gatekeepers, and a public mood that turns without warning. For “teenage idols,” that’s especially brutal: the product is youth itself, and youth expires on schedule.
Context matters: Sherman’s era was pre-social media, when idols were manufactured through radio, TV, and magazines. Today’s pipeline looks different, but the myth is the same: that stardom can be engineered if you master the right tricks. Sherman’s line refuses to sell that myth. It also quietly absolves the ones who don’t “make it,” suggesting failure isn’t always personal. In a culture obsessed with hacks and branding, his non-answer is the honest answer - and a rare kindness.
Sherman’s phrasing does two things at once. “As far as advice” narrows his authority on purpose, dodging the guru role that aging pop figures are pushed into. And “no formula” punctures the fantasy that fame is a meritocratic recipe - rehearse, smile, be wholesome, repeat - when the real determinants are timing, industry gatekeepers, and a public mood that turns without warning. For “teenage idols,” that’s especially brutal: the product is youth itself, and youth expires on schedule.
Context matters: Sherman’s era was pre-social media, when idols were manufactured through radio, TV, and magazines. Today’s pipeline looks different, but the myth is the same: that stardom can be engineered if you master the right tricks. Sherman’s line refuses to sell that myth. It also quietly absolves the ones who don’t “make it,” suggesting failure isn’t always personal. In a culture obsessed with hacks and branding, his non-answer is the honest answer - and a rare kindness.
Quote Details
| Topic | Youth |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Bobby
Add to List






