"As long as Muslims were confident they could not be defeated, but now we are just puppets"
About this Quote
Confidence is doing heavy political work here: it gets framed not as a feeling but as a strategic asset, the difference between agency and humiliation. Bashir’s line isn’t aimed at non-Muslims; it’s an intra-community provocation, a rebuke delivered as diagnosis. The claim that “Muslims were confident they could not be defeated” reaches for a mythic past of inevitability, a time when victory felt prewritten. That kind of nostalgia flattens history on purpose: it turns complex defeats, compromises, and internal disputes into a single moral narrative of decline.
“Puppets” is the loaded hinge. It implies not only weakness but ventriloquism: someone else’s hand inside your choices. In Islamist rhetoric, that “someone” is usually a mix of Western powers, local secular elites, and state security apparatuses. The subtext is conspiratorial, but its emotional logic is clearer than its geopolitics: if you feel powerless, it’s because you’ve been made powerless. That move offers relief (your failures aren’t your fault) and a target (the collaborators). It also smuggles in an implied prescription: break the strings by rejecting democratic politics, international norms, or “moderate” religious leadership.
Context matters because Bashir has long spoken from the posture of the besieged ideologue, often around moments when militant networks are rolled up, public sympathy shifts, or governments tighten counterterror measures. The sentence reads like recruitment copy disguised as lament: mourn the lost certainty, then convert shame into resolve. The rhetoric doesn’t argue; it polarizes, making dignity contingent on confrontation.
“Puppets” is the loaded hinge. It implies not only weakness but ventriloquism: someone else’s hand inside your choices. In Islamist rhetoric, that “someone” is usually a mix of Western powers, local secular elites, and state security apparatuses. The subtext is conspiratorial, but its emotional logic is clearer than its geopolitics: if you feel powerless, it’s because you’ve been made powerless. That move offers relief (your failures aren’t your fault) and a target (the collaborators). It also smuggles in an implied prescription: break the strings by rejecting democratic politics, international norms, or “moderate” religious leadership.
Context matters because Bashir has long spoken from the posture of the besieged ideologue, often around moments when militant networks are rolled up, public sympathy shifts, or governments tighten counterterror measures. The sentence reads like recruitment copy disguised as lament: mourn the lost certainty, then convert shame into resolve. The rhetoric doesn’t argue; it polarizes, making dignity contingent on confrontation.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Abu
Add to List





