"As you know, I am neither Roman Catholic, Protestant Episcopalian, nor Presbyterian, nor am I an Irishman"
About this Quote
Bright’s line is the Victorian equivalent of a raised eyebrow delivered in Parliament: a dry recital of what he is not, designed to expose how politics was being reduced to tribal sorting. By stacking labels - Roman Catholic, Protestant Episcopalian, Presbyterian - he parades the period’s denominational pecking order, then caps it with “nor am I an Irishman,” the identity that, in British debate, often functioned less as nationality than as a convenient suspicion. The humor isn’t decorative; it’s tactical. Listing affiliations like items on a blacklist turns the listener into a witness to the absurdity.
The intent is defensive and accusatory at once. Bright, a Radical Liberal and Quaker, is pushing back against insinuations that his views must be read through sectarian or ethnic loyalty. He refuses the premise that a political argument needs a “proper” religious passport. At the same time, he’s calling out the ugly arithmetic of the day: that Catholics were presumed disloyal, dissenting Protestants politically suspect, and Irishness itself treated as a contagion in debates over home rule and reform.
Subtext: you can stop interrogating my identity and start answering my argument. Bright’s rhetorical power comes from letting prejudice reveal itself. He doesn’t denounce bigotry in grand terms; he simply mirrors the categories back, so the audience hears how petty and paranoiac the frame has become. It’s also a reminder that 19th-century British liberalism wasn’t just about policies, but about who counted as legitimately “British” enough to speak.
The intent is defensive and accusatory at once. Bright, a Radical Liberal and Quaker, is pushing back against insinuations that his views must be read through sectarian or ethnic loyalty. He refuses the premise that a political argument needs a “proper” religious passport. At the same time, he’s calling out the ugly arithmetic of the day: that Catholics were presumed disloyal, dissenting Protestants politically suspect, and Irishness itself treated as a contagion in debates over home rule and reform.
Subtext: you can stop interrogating my identity and start answering my argument. Bright’s rhetorical power comes from letting prejudice reveal itself. He doesn’t denounce bigotry in grand terms; he simply mirrors the categories back, so the audience hears how petty and paranoiac the frame has become. It’s also a reminder that 19th-century British liberalism wasn’t just about policies, but about who counted as legitimately “British” enough to speak.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by John
Add to List



