"Asking a working writer what he thinks about critics is like asking a lamp-post what it feels about dogs"
About this Quote
Hampton’s line is a polite cocktail-party smile with a razor tucked behind it. A lamp-post doesn’t “feel” anything about dogs; it simply stands there and gets used. That’s the joke, and it’s also the point: the working writer, in Hampton’s framing, is a fixed object in the street-level economy of culture, while critics are passing traffic - and sometimes, bluntly, the creatures that mark territory.
The insult lands because it dodges the usual writer-versus-critic melodrama. Hampton isn’t arguing that critics are stupid, or irrelevant, or evil. He’s implying something colder: the relationship is structurally asymmetrical. Writers make the thing; critics arrive after the fact to interpret, judge, and (at worst) relieve themselves. Asking the writer for an opinion becomes as absurd as asking infrastructure to critique behavior. The writer’s “feelings” aren’t just unhelpful; they’re beside the point.
Coming from a playwright, the image carries extra bite. Theatre is one of the most critic-dependent art forms: reviews can make or break a run, shape a reputation, even decide whether a play enters the repertoire. Hampton’s lamp-post metaphor captures that vulnerability without confessing it. He performs toughness by turning himself into street furniture: durable, public, exposed. The subtext is resignation dressed up as contempt. Critics aren’t peers in a debate; they’re a condition of the job, like weather, like foot traffic, like dogs.
The insult lands because it dodges the usual writer-versus-critic melodrama. Hampton isn’t arguing that critics are stupid, or irrelevant, or evil. He’s implying something colder: the relationship is structurally asymmetrical. Writers make the thing; critics arrive after the fact to interpret, judge, and (at worst) relieve themselves. Asking the writer for an opinion becomes as absurd as asking infrastructure to critique behavior. The writer’s “feelings” aren’t just unhelpful; they’re beside the point.
Coming from a playwright, the image carries extra bite. Theatre is one of the most critic-dependent art forms: reviews can make or break a run, shape a reputation, even decide whether a play enters the repertoire. Hampton’s lamp-post metaphor captures that vulnerability without confessing it. He performs toughness by turning himself into street furniture: durable, public, exposed. The subtext is resignation dressed up as contempt. Critics aren’t peers in a debate; they’re a condition of the job, like weather, like foot traffic, like dogs.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Christopher
Add to List







