"At best the family teaches the finest things human beings can learn from one another generosity and love. But it is also, all too often, where we learn nasty things like hate, rage and shame"
About this Quote
Family, in Ehrenreich's hands, isn't a sacred refuge; it's a training ground. The opening clause, "At best", punctures the Hallmark fantasy with a writer's scalpel: she grants the ideal before dragging it into reality. That pivot is the engine of the sentence. It forces the reader to hold two truths at once: the family as our first site of moral education, and as our first exposure to moral injury.
Her phrasing is deliberately plain - "generosity and love" set against "hate, rage and shame" - but the politics are sharp. Ehrenreich spent a career suspicious of institutions that market themselves as natural, benevolent, and beyond critique. Here, "the family" functions like her broader targets (workplace, healthcare, American optimism): a system that can distribute care while also reproducing power. The line "we learn" is the quiet accusation. These aren't private quirks; they're taught, modeled, enforced. Shame, especially, signals the family's role as a miniature social order: it disciplines bodies and desires long before the state or the boss shows up.
Context matters: writing in an era when "family values" rhetoric was routinely deployed to shut down discussions of abuse, inequality, queerness, and women's autonomy. Ehrenreich's intent isn't to sneer at affection; it's to deny the family its moral immunity. The subtext is an invitation to stop treating harm as an exception to the family story and start seeing it as one of its predictable outcomes - which is exactly why the sentence lands with such calm menace.
Her phrasing is deliberately plain - "generosity and love" set against "hate, rage and shame" - but the politics are sharp. Ehrenreich spent a career suspicious of institutions that market themselves as natural, benevolent, and beyond critique. Here, "the family" functions like her broader targets (workplace, healthcare, American optimism): a system that can distribute care while also reproducing power. The line "we learn" is the quiet accusation. These aren't private quirks; they're taught, modeled, enforced. Shame, especially, signals the family's role as a miniature social order: it disciplines bodies and desires long before the state or the boss shows up.
Context matters: writing in an era when "family values" rhetoric was routinely deployed to shut down discussions of abuse, inequality, queerness, and women's autonomy. Ehrenreich's intent isn't to sneer at affection; it's to deny the family its moral immunity. The subtext is an invitation to stop treating harm as an exception to the family story and start seeing it as one of its predictable outcomes - which is exactly why the sentence lands with such calm menace.
Quote Details
| Topic | Family |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Barbara
Add to List





