"At one level you're condemned to the voice you have. But within those confines, you have a certain amount of freedom to range among your possible voices"
About this Quote
Guterson frames creativity as a prison break that never quite clears the walls. “Condemned” is a deliberately harsh verb for something as ordinary as a speaking voice, smuggling in the writer’s most persistent anxiety: that identity arrives preloaded, with limits you didn’t choose. Accent, cadence, class markers, region, even temperament - the stuff readers and listeners instantly “clock” - becomes fate. He’s puncturing the romantic fantasy that an artist can simply reinvent themselves from scratch.
Then he pivots, not to liberation, but to a more interesting bargain: constraint as a working space. “Within those confines” carries the sound of a craft lesson and a moral lesson at once. You can’t opt out of your given instrument, but you can learn its registers. The phrase “range among your possible voices” is where the writer’s real argument lives. Voice isn’t singular; it’s a set of selves you can legitimately inhabit without lying. That’s a subtle ethical stance for a novelist: invention is allowed, even required, but it must remain tethered to what you can honestly render.
The context is the ongoing American fixation on “finding your voice,” often marketed as a mystical breakthrough. Guterson demystifies it into discipline and choice. He also hints at why voice matters culturally right now: audiences reward authenticity, but they also punish sameness. His solution isn’t to chase novelty; it’s to explore variation inside identity - a roomy, realistic definition of artistic freedom.
Then he pivots, not to liberation, but to a more interesting bargain: constraint as a working space. “Within those confines” carries the sound of a craft lesson and a moral lesson at once. You can’t opt out of your given instrument, but you can learn its registers. The phrase “range among your possible voices” is where the writer’s real argument lives. Voice isn’t singular; it’s a set of selves you can legitimately inhabit without lying. That’s a subtle ethical stance for a novelist: invention is allowed, even required, but it must remain tethered to what you can honestly render.
The context is the ongoing American fixation on “finding your voice,” often marketed as a mystical breakthrough. Guterson demystifies it into discipline and choice. He also hints at why voice matters culturally right now: audiences reward authenticity, but they also punish sameness. His solution isn’t to chase novelty; it’s to explore variation inside identity - a roomy, realistic definition of artistic freedom.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by David
Add to List
