"At risk of sounding foully pompous I think that writers' groups are probably very useful at the beginning of a writing career"
About this Quote
Cornwell opens with a preemptive wince: "At risk of sounding foully pompous" is less throat-clearing than tactic. He knows that advice from a successful novelist can land as condescension, so he stages humility before delivering the verdict. The phrase "foully pompous" is deliberately overstated, almost comic in its self-disgust, a way of disarming the reader and signaling, I’m aware of the power dynamic here.
Then he adds another softener: "probably". Cornwell isn’t issuing doctrine; he’s protecting his claim from the absolutism that so often makes writing advice unbearable. That hedging also smuggles in a more pointed message: if you’re early in your career, you don’t yet have reliable internal calibration. You need external friction - feedback, deadlines, a room where someone asks what you meant and whether you pulled it off. Writers' groups become training wheels not because they create genius, but because they create repetition, accountability, and the normalizing shock of being read by strangers.
The subtext is quietly pragmatic: usefulness is time-bound. "At the beginning" suggests an off-ramp. Once a writer has developed taste, stamina, and a working process, group consensus can start to feel like noise, or worse, a brake on risk. Coming from Cornwell - a career craftsman known for narrative momentum and readable historical fiction - the context is revealing. This is advice rooted in practice, not mystique: writing is a job you learn by doing it in public before you’re brave enough to do it alone.
Then he adds another softener: "probably". Cornwell isn’t issuing doctrine; he’s protecting his claim from the absolutism that so often makes writing advice unbearable. That hedging also smuggles in a more pointed message: if you’re early in your career, you don’t yet have reliable internal calibration. You need external friction - feedback, deadlines, a room where someone asks what you meant and whether you pulled it off. Writers' groups become training wheels not because they create genius, but because they create repetition, accountability, and the normalizing shock of being read by strangers.
The subtext is quietly pragmatic: usefulness is time-bound. "At the beginning" suggests an off-ramp. Once a writer has developed taste, stamina, and a working process, group consensus can start to feel like noise, or worse, a brake on risk. Coming from Cornwell - a career craftsman known for narrative momentum and readable historical fiction - the context is revealing. This is advice rooted in practice, not mystique: writing is a job you learn by doing it in public before you’re brave enough to do it alone.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Bernard
Add to List




