"AT&T will not block access to the public Internet or degrade service, period"
About this Quote
A promise with a hard stop: "period". Whitacre isn’t just assuring customers; he’s trying to foreclose debate. The line is engineered to sound like a moral stance, but it’s really a negotiating position delivered as virtue. In the mid-2000s, as broadband providers were getting nervous about Google, VoIP, and streaming riding "for free" on their networks, the net neutrality fight was turning from policy seminar to public brawl. This quote shows a CEO attempting to seize the language before regulators and advocates do.
The specific intent is reputational triage. By framing AT&T as a guardian of the "public Internet", Whitacre borrows civic vocabulary to describe a privately owned chokepoint. The term "public" is doing heavy lifting: it implies a commons while sidestepping the fact that the company controls last-mile access for millions. It’s an elegant bit of corporate rhetorical jujitsu: assert openness, keep authority.
The subtext is conditional. "Will not block" and "or degrade" are the sins people can easily imagine and hate. The more profitable gray areas - paid prioritization, zero-rating, usage caps, interconnection tolls - aren’t mentioned. "Period" functions as a confidence marker meant to make those omissions invisible, turning a narrow pledge into a broad exoneration.
Context matters: Whitacre had previously complained that internet companies were "using my pipes", a line that made AT&T look like it wanted to charge gatekeeping rents. This quote is the corrective memo, drafted for lawmakers and headlines: calm the public, soften scrutiny, keep the business model flexible.
The specific intent is reputational triage. By framing AT&T as a guardian of the "public Internet", Whitacre borrows civic vocabulary to describe a privately owned chokepoint. The term "public" is doing heavy lifting: it implies a commons while sidestepping the fact that the company controls last-mile access for millions. It’s an elegant bit of corporate rhetorical jujitsu: assert openness, keep authority.
The subtext is conditional. "Will not block" and "or degrade" are the sins people can easily imagine and hate. The more profitable gray areas - paid prioritization, zero-rating, usage caps, interconnection tolls - aren’t mentioned. "Period" functions as a confidence marker meant to make those omissions invisible, turning a narrow pledge into a broad exoneration.
Context matters: Whitacre had previously complained that internet companies were "using my pipes", a line that made AT&T look like it wanted to charge gatekeeping rents. This quote is the corrective memo, drafted for lawmakers and headlines: calm the public, soften scrutiny, keep the business model flexible.
Quote Details
| Topic | Internet |
|---|
More Quotes by Edward
Add to List
