"Auschwitz is a place in which tragedy cannot occur"
About this Quote
Edward Bond compresses a radical claim into a stark paradox. Tragedy presupposes a moral and symbolic order in which human choices matter, conflicts have intelligible stakes, and suffering leads to recognition. From Aristotle onward, tragedy has required agency, error, and consequence, a framework that allows audiences to experience catharsis and to judge the world as, however broken, still legible. Auschwitz annihilates that framework. It is a machine designed to erase personhood, to organize murder bureaucratically, to replace choice with coercion and meaning with administrative procedure. Where agency is stripped, where victims are selected for extermination rather than entangled in a fateful conflict, the tragic form collapses.
Bond is resisting the ethical temptation to aestheticize the Holocaust. To call Auschwitz tragic risks conferring on it the nobility, inevitability, and metaphysical resonance that tragedy often carries. It might make atrocity appear as destiny, or as a fall from greatness produced by error. But Auschwitz was not destiny; it was a human crime engineered by a modern state, preventable and contingent. The dead are not tragic heroes; to treat them as such would substitute art for responsibility and turn horror into spectacle. Hence tragedy cannot occur there because the conditions that would make tragic comprehension possible are precisely what the camp destroys: reciprocity, deliberation, the public space where action and judgment can meet.
The line also marks a crisis for art after the Holocaust, echoing Adorno’s bleak warning about poetry after Auschwitz. Bond, a playwright of political ferocity, is not renouncing drama but redefining its duty. If traditional tragedy is disabled by the camp, theater must find forms that expose the social mechanisms producing violence and that help audiences recover the capacity for judgment. The aim is not catharsis but lucid outrage and responsibility, so that what is beyond tragedy remains beyond repetition.
Bond is resisting the ethical temptation to aestheticize the Holocaust. To call Auschwitz tragic risks conferring on it the nobility, inevitability, and metaphysical resonance that tragedy often carries. It might make atrocity appear as destiny, or as a fall from greatness produced by error. But Auschwitz was not destiny; it was a human crime engineered by a modern state, preventable and contingent. The dead are not tragic heroes; to treat them as such would substitute art for responsibility and turn horror into spectacle. Hence tragedy cannot occur there because the conditions that would make tragic comprehension possible are precisely what the camp destroys: reciprocity, deliberation, the public space where action and judgment can meet.
The line also marks a crisis for art after the Holocaust, echoing Adorno’s bleak warning about poetry after Auschwitz. Bond, a playwright of political ferocity, is not renouncing drama but redefining its duty. If traditional tragedy is disabled by the camp, theater must find forms that expose the social mechanisms producing violence and that help audiences recover the capacity for judgment. The aim is not catharsis but lucid outrage and responsibility, so that what is beyond tragedy remains beyond repetition.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|
More Quotes by Edward
Add to List
