"Ban partial-birth abortion except to save mother's life"
About this Quote
A sentence like this is built to sound morally absolute while staying politically elastic. “Ban” signals certainty and authority; it asks for no debate, only enforcement. “Partial-birth abortion” does the heavy lifting rhetorically: it’s a non-medical label engineered for maximum visceral reaction, splicing a clinical reality into an image that feels like infanticide. The term collapses nuance on purpose, turning a complex set of late-pregnancy circumstances into a single, condemnable act.
Then comes the escape hatch: “except to save mother’s life.” That clause is less compassion than strategy. It inoculates the speaker against the charge of extremism while keeping the exception narrow enough to satisfy a base that treats abortion as a moral emergency, not a health service. Notice what’s missing: no mention of the mother’s health, fetal nonviability, rape or incest, or medical ambiguity. In real-world medicine, “life” and “health” are rarely cleanly separable; the line gets drawn after the crisis, not before. Politically, though, “life” sounds objective and rare, making the ban feel like it targets only the most “unthinkable” cases.
The context is the late-1990s/early-2000s fight over the federal Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Act, when Republicans used this phrasing to reframe abortion politics around a late-term scenario most voters found unsettling. The intent isn’t just policy; it’s narrative control: define the procedure in emotive language, set the terms of moral judgment, and force opponents into the position of defending something framed as indefensible.
Then comes the escape hatch: “except to save mother’s life.” That clause is less compassion than strategy. It inoculates the speaker against the charge of extremism while keeping the exception narrow enough to satisfy a base that treats abortion as a moral emergency, not a health service. Notice what’s missing: no mention of the mother’s health, fetal nonviability, rape or incest, or medical ambiguity. In real-world medicine, “life” and “health” are rarely cleanly separable; the line gets drawn after the crisis, not before. Politically, though, “life” sounds objective and rare, making the ban feel like it targets only the most “unthinkable” cases.
The context is the late-1990s/early-2000s fight over the federal Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Act, when Republicans used this phrasing to reframe abortion politics around a late-term scenario most voters found unsettling. The intent isn’t just policy; it’s narrative control: define the procedure in emotive language, set the terms of moral judgment, and force opponents into the position of defending something framed as indefensible.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|
More Quotes by Jerry
Add to List
