"Base souls have no faith in great individuals"
About this Quote
“Base souls” is a deliberately insulting category: Rousseau isn’t neutrally observing skepticism, he’s diagnosing a moral and psychological inability to recognize greatness. The jab matters because it reverses what Enlightenment rationalists often prized in themselves: doubt. In Rousseau’s hands, disbelief in “great individuals” isn’t sophistication; it’s smallness masquerading as prudence.
The line works by smuggling an argument about imagination and selfhood into a single moral sentence. To have “faith” in greatness is not just to admire someone; it’s to believe that human nature can exceed the cramped, transactional version of life that “base” people accept as normal. Rousseau implies that cynicism is frequently a defensive posture: if you can’t conceive of noble motives, you never have to risk them. Deny the possibility of uncommon virtue and you’re spared the discomfort of measuring yourself against it.
Context sharpens the edge. Rousseau’s era was busy dismantling inherited authority, especially the “great man” aura of kings, clerics, and aristocrats. Rousseau participates in that demolition job, but he’s also wary of what replaces it: a cool, salon-bred irony, the smug conviction that everyone is corrupt, that ideals are just costumes for self-interest. His insult targets that posture. He’s not rehabilitating hierarchy; he’s defending moral aspiration against fashionable debunking.
The subtext is a warning: a society that treats greatness as a con is a society training itself to prefer mediocrity. When disbelief becomes identity, it stops being critical thinking and becomes a cage.
The line works by smuggling an argument about imagination and selfhood into a single moral sentence. To have “faith” in greatness is not just to admire someone; it’s to believe that human nature can exceed the cramped, transactional version of life that “base” people accept as normal. Rousseau implies that cynicism is frequently a defensive posture: if you can’t conceive of noble motives, you never have to risk them. Deny the possibility of uncommon virtue and you’re spared the discomfort of measuring yourself against it.
Context sharpens the edge. Rousseau’s era was busy dismantling inherited authority, especially the “great man” aura of kings, clerics, and aristocrats. Rousseau participates in that demolition job, but he’s also wary of what replaces it: a cool, salon-bred irony, the smug conviction that everyone is corrupt, that ideals are just costumes for self-interest. His insult targets that posture. He’s not rehabilitating hierarchy; he’s defending moral aspiration against fashionable debunking.
The subtext is a warning: a society that treats greatness as a con is a society training itself to prefer mediocrity. When disbelief becomes identity, it stops being critical thinking and becomes a cage.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Jean-Jacques
Add to List
