"Basically, fiction is people. You can't write fiction about ideas"
About this Quote
Sturgeon’s line is a rebuke to a certain sci-fi temptation: the clever premise that struts onto the page and forgets to bleed. Coming from a writer who helped push midcentury speculative fiction toward psychology and intimacy, it’s also a declaration of craft values. He’s not denying that fiction can contain ideas; he’s insisting that ideas only become legible, and emotionally persuasive, when they’re embodied in human behavior - in fear, vanity, tenderness, boredom, shame. In other words: the brain needs a nervous system.
The bluntness of “Basically” matters. It’s workshop-talk, almost impatient, aimed at younger writers who mistake concept for story. Sturgeon is quietly policing the border between argument and narrative. An essay can win by being right. Fiction wins by making us care what it feels like to be wrong, or to want the wrong thing, or to choose the wrong person. “You can’t write fiction about ideas” is less a prohibition than a warning about dead air: pages where the author is talking at the reader through characters who exist mainly as mouthpieces.
There’s subtext, too, about humility. Ideas are clean; people are not. Fiction’s job is to get messy - to let motives conflict, to let consequences surprise, to let the theme emerge from pressure rather than proclamation. For a genre long stereotyped as “ideas with ray guns,” Sturgeon is staking a humanist claim: the future is interesting only insofar as it changes what it costs to love, to lie, to survive.
The bluntness of “Basically” matters. It’s workshop-talk, almost impatient, aimed at younger writers who mistake concept for story. Sturgeon is quietly policing the border between argument and narrative. An essay can win by being right. Fiction wins by making us care what it feels like to be wrong, or to want the wrong thing, or to choose the wrong person. “You can’t write fiction about ideas” is less a prohibition than a warning about dead air: pages where the author is talking at the reader through characters who exist mainly as mouthpieces.
There’s subtext, too, about humility. Ideas are clean; people are not. Fiction’s job is to get messy - to let motives conflict, to let consequences surprise, to let the theme emerge from pressure rather than proclamation. For a genre long stereotyped as “ideas with ray guns,” Sturgeon is staking a humanist claim: the future is interesting only insofar as it changes what it costs to love, to lie, to survive.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Theodore
Add to List


