"Be a philosopher but, amid all your philosophy be still a man"
About this Quote
Hume slips a needle into the balloon of high-mindedness: think rigorously, sure, but don’t let the rigor anesthetize you. “Be a philosopher” is a nod to the Enlightenment project he helped define - subject belief to scrutiny, distrust easy metaphysics, insist on evidence. Then comes the pivot: “amid all your philosophy be still a man.” Not “be still human” in a sentimental way, but a corrective aimed at the kind of thinker who tries to live as if reason were the whole of consciousness.
The subtext is deeply Humean. He believed our mental lives are powered less by pure rational command than by habit, sentiment, and social feeling. Reason, for Hume, is limited; it doesn’t generate ends so much as calculate means. That’s why the warning lands: philosophy becomes dangerous when it pretends to replace ordinary life instead of clarifying it. Skepticism can curdle into paralysis; abstraction can harden into arrogance; moral theory can drift into bloodless geometry.
Context matters: Hume writes in a moment when “philosopher” can imply a new secular priesthood, a class of minds tempted to float above the mess of appetite, friendship, humor, and civic duty. He’s resisting the fantasy of the disembodied intellect. The line works because it’s both permission and rebuke: permission to return to the table, the street, the joke - and rebuke to anyone who uses philosophy as an excuse to opt out of sympathy. The best thinking, Hume suggests, keeps its hands dirty.
The subtext is deeply Humean. He believed our mental lives are powered less by pure rational command than by habit, sentiment, and social feeling. Reason, for Hume, is limited; it doesn’t generate ends so much as calculate means. That’s why the warning lands: philosophy becomes dangerous when it pretends to replace ordinary life instead of clarifying it. Skepticism can curdle into paralysis; abstraction can harden into arrogance; moral theory can drift into bloodless geometry.
Context matters: Hume writes in a moment when “philosopher” can imply a new secular priesthood, a class of minds tempted to float above the mess of appetite, friendship, humor, and civic duty. He’s resisting the fantasy of the disembodied intellect. The line works because it’s both permission and rebuke: permission to return to the table, the street, the joke - and rebuke to anyone who uses philosophy as an excuse to opt out of sympathy. The best thinking, Hume suggests, keeps its hands dirty.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by David
Add to List





