"Because artists can be extremely eccentric and insane, and unfortunately, the people they hurt the most are the people that are closest to them"
About this Quote
Maynard James Keenan isn’t romanticizing the “tortured genius” here; he’s putting it on trial. The line lands because it refuses the cozy version of artistic eccentricity as a charming brand trait and treats it as a liability with a blast radius. “Extremely eccentric and insane” is blunt, almost deliberately unpoetic, the kind of phrasing that sounds like someone choosing accountability over mystique. It’s a musician yanking the curtain back on the backstage mythmaking.
The specific intent is cautionary and confessional at once: a warning to fans who confuse intensity with virtue, and a nod to the collateral damage that often gets edited out of the legend. The subtext is that creativity can function like a permission slip. When you’re rewarded for being volatile, you start to confuse dysfunction with authenticity; worse, the industry and audience can enable it, framing harm as “part of the process.”
The second clause is where the real indictment sits: “unfortunately, the people they hurt the most are the people that are closest to them.” That’s not abstract ethics; it’s domestic geography. The harm doesn’t primarily happen in interviews or onstage. It happens in kitchens, tour-bus silences, relationships that have to absorb the mood swings, ego, addiction, and emotional absenteeism that get excused as artistic temperament.
Keenan’s broader cultural context matters: rock and alternative music have long traded in the archetype of the brilliant wreck. His line pushes back against fan complicity and artist self-mythology, insisting that the cost of the “genius” narrative is often paid by partners, family, and bandmates who never asked to be part of the art.
The specific intent is cautionary and confessional at once: a warning to fans who confuse intensity with virtue, and a nod to the collateral damage that often gets edited out of the legend. The subtext is that creativity can function like a permission slip. When you’re rewarded for being volatile, you start to confuse dysfunction with authenticity; worse, the industry and audience can enable it, framing harm as “part of the process.”
The second clause is where the real indictment sits: “unfortunately, the people they hurt the most are the people that are closest to them.” That’s not abstract ethics; it’s domestic geography. The harm doesn’t primarily happen in interviews or onstage. It happens in kitchens, tour-bus silences, relationships that have to absorb the mood swings, ego, addiction, and emotional absenteeism that get excused as artistic temperament.
Keenan’s broader cultural context matters: rock and alternative music have long traded in the archetype of the brilliant wreck. His line pushes back against fan complicity and artist self-mythology, insisting that the cost of the “genius” narrative is often paid by partners, family, and bandmates who never asked to be part of the art.
Quote Details
| Topic | Family |
|---|
More Quotes by Maynard
Add to List
