"Because its hard to realize now that that was the end of the great depression, you know. All of a sudden all of this is in front of me and I'm solvent, you know. I'm making some money and I know where my next meal is coming from, and I have a new pair of shoes and that's it"
About this Quote
The line lands like a quiet plot twist: the Great Depression doesn not end with a ticker-tape headline, it ends with shoes. McCloskey is flattening a grand national narrative into a single, almost embarrassingly modest inventory of relief: solvent, fed, shod. That compression is the point. It exposes how economic catastrophe is experienced less as an era and more as a daily math problem you do with your stomach.
The intent feels documentary rather than literary. McCloskey isn’t polishing the memory; he’s keeping the hesitations and the repeated "you know", which function like a moral disclaimer. He’s wary of sounding melodramatic about scarcity, yet the repetition betrays how unbelievable stability still feels. "All of a sudden" is doing heavy lifting: not because life actually changes overnight, but because hindsight turns slow improvement into a cliff-edge moment. The mind prefers a clean before-and-after.
There’s also a sly critique of our historical imagination. "Hard to realize now" suggests a later audience cushioned by distance, prone to treating the Depression like sepia tone. McCloskey yanks the camera back to what counted as winning: not prosperity, just predictability. "And that’s it" is both gratitude and accusation. Gratitude, because basic security is intoxicating after deprivation; accusation, because a society that can make "new pair of shoes" feel like a miracle has already admitted how low the bar was set.
Contextually, it reads as post-crisis testimony: an artist remembering the moment survival stopped being precarious and became merely ordinary, which is its own kind of luxury.
The intent feels documentary rather than literary. McCloskey isn’t polishing the memory; he’s keeping the hesitations and the repeated "you know", which function like a moral disclaimer. He’s wary of sounding melodramatic about scarcity, yet the repetition betrays how unbelievable stability still feels. "All of a sudden" is doing heavy lifting: not because life actually changes overnight, but because hindsight turns slow improvement into a cliff-edge moment. The mind prefers a clean before-and-after.
There’s also a sly critique of our historical imagination. "Hard to realize now" suggests a later audience cushioned by distance, prone to treating the Depression like sepia tone. McCloskey yanks the camera back to what counted as winning: not prosperity, just predictability. "And that’s it" is both gratitude and accusation. Gratitude, because basic security is intoxicating after deprivation; accusation, because a society that can make "new pair of shoes" feel like a miracle has already admitted how low the bar was set.
Contextually, it reads as post-crisis testimony: an artist remembering the moment survival stopped being precarious and became merely ordinary, which is its own kind of luxury.
Quote Details
| Topic | Tough Times |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List




