"Being in a floodplain is like sitting down in a bathtub"
About this Quote
It lands as a throwaway line, but it’s really a warning disguised as a shrug. “Being in a floodplain is like sitting down in a bathtub” uses the most domestic, unglamorous image possible to puncture the fantasy that nature is negotiable. A bathtub is designed to hold water; you don’t blame it for getting wet. Hunter’s analogy quietly shifts responsibility from the river to the humans who insist on treating geography like a suggestion.
The intent is plainspoken: stop acting surprised. The subtext is sharper. Flood disasters are often narrated as freak events, or “acts of God,” which lets developers, policymakers, and homeowners launder risk into tragedy. Hunter’s bathtub comparison strips away that moral fog. If you put your body in the basin, you’re participating in the conditions that make soaking inevitable. It’s a folk metaphor with teeth.
Context matters: Hunter, as the Grateful Dead’s lyricist, spent a career turning American landscapes into mythic stages while keeping one boot planted in common sense. This line feels like the same sensibility applied to climate and land-use reality: a distrust of heroic narratives, a preference for elemental truths. It also anticipates our current era, where floods are intensified by warming oceans and altered weather patterns, but also by choices: building on floodplains, paving wetlands, treating “100-year floods” as marketing math.
The brilliance is how it denies us melodrama. A bathtub isn’t destiny; it’s a container. Hunter implies that if we don’t like the water, we need to stop climbing in.
The intent is plainspoken: stop acting surprised. The subtext is sharper. Flood disasters are often narrated as freak events, or “acts of God,” which lets developers, policymakers, and homeowners launder risk into tragedy. Hunter’s bathtub comparison strips away that moral fog. If you put your body in the basin, you’re participating in the conditions that make soaking inevitable. It’s a folk metaphor with teeth.
Context matters: Hunter, as the Grateful Dead’s lyricist, spent a career turning American landscapes into mythic stages while keeping one boot planted in common sense. This line feels like the same sensibility applied to climate and land-use reality: a distrust of heroic narratives, a preference for elemental truths. It also anticipates our current era, where floods are intensified by warming oceans and altered weather patterns, but also by choices: building on floodplains, paving wetlands, treating “100-year floods” as marketing math.
The brilliance is how it denies us melodrama. A bathtub isn’t destiny; it’s a container. Hunter implies that if we don’t like the water, we need to stop climbing in.
Quote Details
| Topic | Nature |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List










