"Biology has progressed tremendously due to the model that Darwin put forth. But the black boxes Darwin accepted are now being opened, and our view of the world is again being shaken"
About this Quote
Darwin is framed here less as a finished worldview than as a brilliant temporary scaffolding, and Behe is careful to praise the edifice before questioning the foundation. The opening clause flatters the audience’s respect for scientific success: biology has “progressed tremendously” because Darwin’s model worked. That concession isn’t politeness; it’s rhetorical positioning. By granting Darwin credit, Behe aims to make his next move look like science’s natural evolution, not a culture-war ambush.
“Black boxes” is the key piece of language. In engineering, a black box is something you can use without knowing its inner workings. Behe’s subtext: Darwinian explanations relied on mechanisms they couldn’t yet describe at the molecular level, and modern biology now has the tools to pry them open. The phrase is also a subtle indictment: what was once an acceptable placeholder can, in his telling, start to look like an evasion.
Then comes the promised upheaval: “our view of the world is again being shaken.” That’s not a narrow claim about a particular pathway or protein complex; it’s a bid for paradigm-shift energy. The word “again” deliberately echoes past revolutions (Copernicus, Darwin himself), inviting readers to imagine Behe’s project as the next historical turn.
Context matters because Behe is a leading voice associated with intelligent design. So the “opening” of black boxes doesn’t just mean deeper naturalistic explanation; it signals an argument that molecular complexity strains Darwin’s gradualism and may point beyond standard evolutionary mechanisms. The quote works by coupling deference to Darwin with the thrill of disruption, wrapping a controversial thesis in the prestige language of scientific progress.
“Black boxes” is the key piece of language. In engineering, a black box is something you can use without knowing its inner workings. Behe’s subtext: Darwinian explanations relied on mechanisms they couldn’t yet describe at the molecular level, and modern biology now has the tools to pry them open. The phrase is also a subtle indictment: what was once an acceptable placeholder can, in his telling, start to look like an evasion.
Then comes the promised upheaval: “our view of the world is again being shaken.” That’s not a narrow claim about a particular pathway or protein complex; it’s a bid for paradigm-shift energy. The word “again” deliberately echoes past revolutions (Copernicus, Darwin himself), inviting readers to imagine Behe’s project as the next historical turn.
Context matters because Behe is a leading voice associated with intelligent design. So the “opening” of black boxes doesn’t just mean deeper naturalistic explanation; it signals an argument that molecular complexity strains Darwin’s gradualism and may point beyond standard evolutionary mechanisms. The quote works by coupling deference to Darwin with the thrill of disruption, wrapping a controversial thesis in the prestige language of scientific progress.
Quote Details
| Topic | Science |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Michael
Add to List




