"Books on horse racing subjects have never done well, and I am told that publishers had come to think of them as the literary version of box office poison"
About this Quote
Publishing is a superstition business dressed up as spreadsheets, and Hillenbrand knows exactly how to needle it. By calling horse-racing books "the literary version of box office poison", she borrows Hollywood's bluntest curse and drops it into the genteel world of trade publishing. The joke lands because the fear is real: whole subjects get tagged as commercially radioactive, not because readers can’t love them, but because gatekeepers have decided they won’t.
The intent is quietly insurgent. Hillenbrand frames the industry's skepticism as received wisdom ("I am told"), distancing herself from the prejudice even as she exposes it. That little clause suggests a chain of whisper-network assumptions: editors warning agents, agents warning authors, everyone bracing for failure before a manuscript even gets a fair read. Horse racing becomes a proxy for any "niche" story publishers preemptively downrank, especially ones associated with old-money sport, gambling, or a fading Americana aesthetic.
The subtext is also a flex. Hillenbrand is famous for turning allegedly unmarketable material into cultural events by writing them as human dramas with velocity, stakes, and character obsession. In that light, "box office poison" reads like a challenge: the problem isn’t the topic, it’s the packaging - and the industry's habit of mistaking past performance for destiny. It’s a critique of risk-aversion masquerading as market insight, delivered with a smile sharp enough to leave a mark.
The intent is quietly insurgent. Hillenbrand frames the industry's skepticism as received wisdom ("I am told"), distancing herself from the prejudice even as she exposes it. That little clause suggests a chain of whisper-network assumptions: editors warning agents, agents warning authors, everyone bracing for failure before a manuscript even gets a fair read. Horse racing becomes a proxy for any "niche" story publishers preemptively downrank, especially ones associated with old-money sport, gambling, or a fading Americana aesthetic.
The subtext is also a flex. Hillenbrand is famous for turning allegedly unmarketable material into cultural events by writing them as human dramas with velocity, stakes, and character obsession. In that light, "box office poison" reads like a challenge: the problem isn’t the topic, it’s the packaging - and the industry's habit of mistaking past performance for destiny. It’s a critique of risk-aversion masquerading as market insight, delivered with a smile sharp enough to leave a mark.
Quote Details
| Topic | Book |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Laura
Add to List
