"Brass bands are all very well in their place - outdoors and several miles away"
About this Quote
Beecham’s line lands like a perfectly timed cymbal crash: polite on the surface, merciless underneath. “All very well in their place” borrows the language of tolerant English civility, the kind that pretends to make room for everyone. Then comes the knife twist: the “place” for brass bands is “outdoors and several miles away.” It’s not simply a snob’s complaint about volume. It’s a conductor-composer staking out an aesthetic hierarchy, drawing a border between music as cultivated art and music as public noise.
The joke works because it mimics reasonable moderation while delivering absolute exclusion. Beecham isn’t arguing that brass is bad; he’s arguing that proximity is the problem. That sidestep lets him sound measured even as he banishes an entire tradition to the horizon. The humor is spatial: distance becomes criticism, and geography becomes taste.
Context matters. Early 20th-century Britain had a booming brass band culture tied to working-class civic life, parks, contests, and industrial towns. Beecham, an emblem of elite orchestral modernity and patronage, represents the concert hall’s controlled acoustics, disciplined timbres, and the prestige economy around “serious” music. His quip is class-coded without saying “class.” It implies that certain sounds belong to certain people, and certain people belong somewhere else.
What makes it endure is its candor dressed as etiquette. It’s gatekeeping with a grin: the kind of line that tells you as much about the speaker’s world as the music he’s pretending to tolerate.
The joke works because it mimics reasonable moderation while delivering absolute exclusion. Beecham isn’t arguing that brass is bad; he’s arguing that proximity is the problem. That sidestep lets him sound measured even as he banishes an entire tradition to the horizon. The humor is spatial: distance becomes criticism, and geography becomes taste.
Context matters. Early 20th-century Britain had a booming brass band culture tied to working-class civic life, parks, contests, and industrial towns. Beecham, an emblem of elite orchestral modernity and patronage, represents the concert hall’s controlled acoustics, disciplined timbres, and the prestige economy around “serious” music. His quip is class-coded without saying “class.” It implies that certain sounds belong to certain people, and certain people belong somewhere else.
What makes it endure is its candor dressed as etiquette. It’s gatekeeping with a grin: the kind of line that tells you as much about the speaker’s world as the music he’s pretending to tolerate.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Thomas
Add to List

