"Broadcasting is really too important to be left to the broadcasters"
About this Quote
A politician’s line that lands like a polite coup: Benn takes a familiar democratic slogan structure ("too important to be left to...") and turns it on the people who normally claim neutrality. Broadcasting, he implies, isn’t a technical trade; it’s a public power. The sting is in the understatement. By framing broadcasters as a narrow interest group rather than guardians of the commons, Benn punctures the comforting myth that media simply “reports” reality.
The intent is corrective and strategic. Benn was a lifelong critic of unaccountable institutions, and this is him naming the quietest form of authority: agenda-setting. Who gets airtime, what counts as “balance,” which stories lead, which voices are deemed credible - those decisions shape public consent as surely as any manifesto. The subtext isn’t anti-journalist; it’s anti-gatekeeper. He’s warning that professional norms and corporate incentives can masquerade as objectivity while reproducing establishment priorities.
Context matters: postwar Britain treated broadcasting as a national utility as much as a cultural product, with the BBC’s Reithian mission and constant political anxiety about bias, class, and state influence. Benn’s line sits inside that tension: he distrusts both government control and market control, so he reaches for a third principle - democratic oversight. Read today, it feels almost prophetic about platform governance and concentrated media ownership. The provocation isn’t “let politicians run the news.” It’s “stop pretending the people who control the microphone shouldn’t be accountable to the people listening.”
The intent is corrective and strategic. Benn was a lifelong critic of unaccountable institutions, and this is him naming the quietest form of authority: agenda-setting. Who gets airtime, what counts as “balance,” which stories lead, which voices are deemed credible - those decisions shape public consent as surely as any manifesto. The subtext isn’t anti-journalist; it’s anti-gatekeeper. He’s warning that professional norms and corporate incentives can masquerade as objectivity while reproducing establishment priorities.
Context matters: postwar Britain treated broadcasting as a national utility as much as a cultural product, with the BBC’s Reithian mission and constant political anxiety about bias, class, and state influence. Benn’s line sits inside that tension: he distrusts both government control and market control, so he reaches for a third principle - democratic oversight. Read today, it feels almost prophetic about platform governance and concentrated media ownership. The provocation isn’t “let politicians run the news.” It’s “stop pretending the people who control the microphone shouldn’t be accountable to the people listening.”
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Tony
Add to List


