"Burning dinner is not incompetence but war"
About this Quote
“Burning dinner is not incompetence but war” flips a domestic mishap into a battlefield report, and the escalation is the point. Marge Piercy isn’t interested in whether the roast is edible; she’s naming the psychic and political pressure baked into “ordinary” women’s work. The line performs a refusal: it rejects the premise that a scorched meal is evidence of personal failure. Instead it frames the kitchen as a front line where expectations, exhaustion, and surveillance collide.
Piercy’s genius is compression. “Not incompetence” swats away the easy, patronizing diagnosis: you’re bad at this. “But war” replaces it with a systemic explanation: you’re fighting. The subtext is about divided labor and divided selves. When your day is already carved up by paid work, caretaking, and the invisible management of a household, the stakes of dinner become absurdly high. A burned pan isn’t a cute anecdote; it’s what happens when you’re required to be efficient, nurturing, attractive, calm, and grateful all at once.
Context matters. Piercy writes out of second-wave feminism’s insistence that the personal is political, and this sentence is that thesis in miniature. It’s also a critique of how domestic labor is treated as both natural and morally loaded: do it flawlessly, and it “doesn’t count” as work; do it imperfectly, and it counts as character. Calling it war exposes the coercion behind the smiley apron, and turns shame into indictment.
Piercy’s genius is compression. “Not incompetence” swats away the easy, patronizing diagnosis: you’re bad at this. “But war” replaces it with a systemic explanation: you’re fighting. The subtext is about divided labor and divided selves. When your day is already carved up by paid work, caretaking, and the invisible management of a household, the stakes of dinner become absurdly high. A burned pan isn’t a cute anecdote; it’s what happens when you’re required to be efficient, nurturing, attractive, calm, and grateful all at once.
Context matters. Piercy writes out of second-wave feminism’s insistence that the personal is political, and this sentence is that thesis in miniature. It’s also a critique of how domestic labor is treated as both natural and morally loaded: do it flawlessly, and it “doesn’t count” as work; do it imperfectly, and it counts as character. Calling it war exposes the coercion behind the smiley apron, and turns shame into indictment.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Marge
Add to List







