"Bush wasn't elected, he was selected - selected by five judges up in Washington who voted along party lines"
About this Quote
Baldwin’s line lands because it’s not trying to litigate 2000 like a law review article; it’s trying to brand it. “Wasn’t elected, he was selected” is tabloid-simple phrasing with a prosecutor’s cadence, built to be repeated at dinner tables and in late-night monologues. The pivot turns a messy democratic process into a single, cinematic act of capture: choice replaced by appointment, consent replaced by choreography.
The specificity is the weapon. “Five judges up in Washington” collapses Bush v. Gore into an image of remote power: a small, insulated club overriding a sprawling electorate. He doesn’t say “the Supreme Court” first; he says “five judges,” stripping away institutional grandeur and leaving a headcount that feels petty and alarming. “Voted along party lines” is the moral verdict. It implies the judiciary, supposedly the last neutral referee, behaved like Congress in robes. The subtext isn’t only that Bush’s win was illegitimate; it’s that the system’s claim to impartiality is a performance, and everyone in the audience is being asked to stop applauding.
Coming from an actor, the accusation doubles as cultural commentary: politics as casting. “Selected” hints at backstage deal-making, at a role filled by insiders rather than earned before the public. It also reflects the early-2000s liberal anger that the recount drama in Florida and the Court’s intervention didn’t just pick a president; it hardened partisan distrust into a permanent posture. Baldwin’s intent is to keep that wound visible, because forgetting would normalize it.
The specificity is the weapon. “Five judges up in Washington” collapses Bush v. Gore into an image of remote power: a small, insulated club overriding a sprawling electorate. He doesn’t say “the Supreme Court” first; he says “five judges,” stripping away institutional grandeur and leaving a headcount that feels petty and alarming. “Voted along party lines” is the moral verdict. It implies the judiciary, supposedly the last neutral referee, behaved like Congress in robes. The subtext isn’t only that Bush’s win was illegitimate; it’s that the system’s claim to impartiality is a performance, and everyone in the audience is being asked to stop applauding.
Coming from an actor, the accusation doubles as cultural commentary: politics as casting. “Selected” hints at backstage deal-making, at a role filled by insiders rather than earned before the public. It also reflects the early-2000s liberal anger that the recount drama in Florida and the Court’s intervention didn’t just pick a president; it hardened partisan distrust into a permanent posture. Baldwin’s intent is to keep that wound visible, because forgetting would normalize it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by Alec
Add to List


