"But, after all, we are a young nation, and vanity is a fault of youth"
About this Quote
A young nation doesn`t just build railroads and constitutions; it builds a self-image, then anxiously checks the mirror. Rebecca H. Davis lands that idea with a deceptively gentle jab: vanity isn`t framed as a moral collapse, but as a developmental stage. The line works because it flatters and scolds at once. Calling the country "young" offers an alibi, a way to treat national bragging as temporary acne rather than a permanent disease. But the second clause tightens the screw. Vanity isn`t inevitable; it`s a fault. Youth explains it, it doesn`t excuse it.
The subtext is about a nation still auditioning for adulthood. In the 19th-century American context Davis inhabited, confidence was a civic project: westward expansion, industrial muscle, the insistence that the United States was not merely new but destined. That project easily slips into performance, the kind of chest-thumping that confuses possibility with proof. Davis is puncturing the tendency to treat national identity as branding.
Her phrasing is also tactical. "After all" signals weary familiarity, as if she has watched this boastfulness recur in speeches, newspapers, and parlor talk. The sentence reads like a quiet corrective aimed at readers who want to feel proud without doing the harder work of becoming worthy of pride. It suggests that maturity, for a country, looks less like louder self-congratulation and more like the humility to see its own flaws clearly.
The subtext is about a nation still auditioning for adulthood. In the 19th-century American context Davis inhabited, confidence was a civic project: westward expansion, industrial muscle, the insistence that the United States was not merely new but destined. That project easily slips into performance, the kind of chest-thumping that confuses possibility with proof. Davis is puncturing the tendency to treat national identity as branding.
Her phrasing is also tactical. "After all" signals weary familiarity, as if she has watched this boastfulness recur in speeches, newspapers, and parlor talk. The sentence reads like a quiet corrective aimed at readers who want to feel proud without doing the harder work of becoming worthy of pride. It suggests that maturity, for a country, looks less like louder self-congratulation and more like the humility to see its own flaws clearly.
Quote Details
| Topic | Youth |
|---|
More Quotes by Rebecca
Add to List











